sergejsha / edge-to-edge Goto Github PK

On Android R, the behaviour of ViewCompat.setOnApplyWindowInsetsListener has changed to support IME (see for example https://proandroiddev.com/exploring-windowinsets-on-android-11-a80cf8fe19be).

I currently have a fragment that is used in two different location in my app:

1. As the main fragment of a single activity
2. As a fragment inside a CoordinatorLayout in another activity

My app is build like so:

1. The fragment calls edgeToEdge() to include padding for the top system bar
2. The CoordinatorLayout also calls edgeToEdge() to include padding for the top system bar

In API 29, the fragment inside the CoordinatorLayout won't get OnApplyWindowInsetsListener called
In API 30, the fragment do get OnApplyWindowInsetsListener called (probably due to the change for the new IME code)

Now, my fix right now is just to check if the fragment is not inside a CoordinatorLayout to call fragment.edgeToEdge().

But I'm wondering if there is anything that could be done in the edge-to-edge library to fix this instead. What do you think?

The navigation bar color is transparent, But the navigationBar in Android Q it displays half black.

Then I check the google calendar app, the navigation bar can be half white. can it be we set the navigationBar transparent, the navigation bar goes with the theme color, Or we can set the navigation bar look the normal color half white?

The Google suggests set the color transparent , so if we set another color can use perform the adapter color change which the Android Q help us achieve the function

It appears that the implementation doesn't work properly when I set edge-to-edge on an Activity. The bottom navigation bar is still fully transparent. For example:

What I want is to have the bottom navigation bar semi-transparent:

My fix is to have the Edge-to-Edge use the "android.R.id.content" view as the root view instead of the decor view.

I have created a project that shows the issue and the fix. See https://github.com/thierryd/EdgeToEdgeActivityIssue

Thanks for such a convenient library.

Wanted to report that the way you suggest in the README file works good for screens with no navigation bar, but for devices with good old navigation bar (like we have in Android versions before 9) setting navigation color to transparent causes issues with these navigation bars making navigation buttons almost invisible.

Here is a screenshot taken from your sample app on Android 7:

I guess it should be mentioned in README that such transparent navigation bar should be set only for values-29 as it is mentioned in Google`s doc: https://developer.android.com/training/gestures/gesturenav#transparent-bars

I will open a PR quit later mentioning it if you don't mind.