Server component won't re-render when deleting all search params about next.js HOT 4 OPEN

Our ecommerce collection pages are often accessed with pre-populated query parameters, and this bug is preventing to go back to the unfiltered version of each collection.

As mentioned by @georgesofianosgr, when landing on a URL with query parameters and then navigating to the same URL without parameters, the RSC fails to execute properly.
Additionally, we've observed another related issue: after multiple transitions between URLs with and without search parameters, the page abruptly stops rendering any markup, with no errors appearing in the browser console.

You can view a video demonstrating both of these issues here:

Should you require it for further analysis, here's the references to the demo of the above video:

• Repo: https://github.com/federicobadini/parameter-reset-test-v14
• Demo: https://parameter-reset-test-v14.vercel.app/

from next.js.

@georgesofianosgr @federicobadini hey guys, did you find any solution? i found myself in the same scenario - i followed next's guide to search and pagination (https://nextjs.org/learn/dashboard-app/adding-search-and-pagination) exactly but i still get this issue.

from next.js.

@mortz123 I personally rolled back to 14.1.4 which does not suffer from this issue.

from next.js.

It can be checked on v14.2.3, too.

In my case,

1. user visits page with search param (ex. ?type=1) GOOD
2. if user performs router replace action with other search param (ex. ?type=2) GOOD
3. if user performs router replace action with search param deleted, it shows first visited state (ex. ?type=1) BAD

So, I think that nextjs does not distinguish "first visited search param state" and "no search param state".

from next.js.