Current sensor: offset and gain errors about sapog HOT 11 CLOSED

Its not that bad:

from sapog.

I get these coefficients:

p = 1.2129   -1.3072

So the measured value from PX4 ESC - 1.3072, then the result multiplied by 1.2002 should yield something close to Unilog.

from sapog.

PX4ESC doesn't measure average current, it's phase current. It converges with average current at 100% thrust.

from sapog.

I did this fit / fix:

transformed = (input + p(2)) * p(1);
    if transformed < 0
        transformed = 0;
    end

And I get this output - blue is the Unilog data, red is the scaled ESC data.

from sapog.

@pavel-kirienko It seems to correlate more or less linearly though, so can we maybe offer the transformed (average) value as well?

from sapog.

I wouldn't expect the coefficients to stay the same for different loads.

Actually, we don't need instant current measurements anymore - it was necessary for earlier revisions of the firmware in order for the variable inductance rotor position detection method to work, which was employed for initial spin-up procedure. In the current implementation, there are only 2 uses for the current measurements:

• Current limiting
• UAVCAN feedback

Which means that we can simply replace the instant current measurements with average, by means of increasing C9 to 1uF. This will effectively drop the corner frequency of the RC filter to approx. 42 Hz, making the PWM synchronization effects negligible.

from sapog.

Can we also filter the value digitally or is this not observable at the current speeds?

from sapog.

ADC sampling is synchronized with PWM and always happens during PWM-on state, so no, we can't filter it digitally.

from sapog.

How fast is the PWM out happening? Any chance to ramp up ADC?

from sapog.

OK, if we added a parallel ADC sampling process that is not synchronized with PWM, then we probably would be able to get appropriate sampling rate to filter it digitally. However:

• this free-running sampling process must somehow not interfere with PWM-synchronized sampling;
• it must cease to generate IRQs after zero-cross, in order to not delay the commutation IRQ that follows ZC detection;
• it must not require significant processing power. This requirement would be easy to implement if we could simply dump the measurements on a circular buffer via DMA (in order to collect them later from non-IRQ handling code), but the appropriate DMA is already used for the PWM-synchronized sampling.

Despite the above, if we were forced to re-design the motor control having digital filtering as a requirement, I'm sure it would be possible.

PWM frequency is 20~50 KHz.

from sapog.

Let me update the schematics with larger C9.

from sapog.