[🐞] If Signal is used by useTask$ it doesn't re-render should it work that way? about qwik HOT 6 OPEN

Let's wait until v2 alpha is out to check if the bug still exists there. In the mean time it would be very helpful to create the repro in https://qwik.dev/playground so that it's easy to test with the alpha

from qwik.

I wanted to take another look and try a few things. It seems the use of await inside useTask is causing the bug. I created an example repo with 3 example components. The only difference between each component is the code within the useTask.
https://stackblitz.com/github/tuurbo/qwik-task-bug?file=src%2Froutes%2Findex.tsx

from qwik.

Looks like there's an issue with the useVisibleTask example too. The page count doesn't increase past 2.

from qwik.

Looks like there's an issue with the useVisibleTask example too. The page count doesn't increase past 2.

I didn't saw it at first, but you are right, maybe that's also a bug?
I have edited the code

    {!loading.value && (
      <input
        type="submit"
        value="Button that works only one time with useVisibleTask$, but always with useTask$, why?"
        onClick$={increase}
      />
    )}
    <input
      type="submit"
      onClick$={increase}
      style={`${loading.value && 'background:red;'}`}
    />

from qwik.

I think I encounter a similar bug in the QwikCityProvider in line 504. The update call routeLocation.isNavigating = false; is triggered, but useTask$ is not always notified. It works with useVisibleTask$ for me.

from qwik.

Here is a slimmed down example

https://qwik.dev/playground/#f=7ZdNb9NAEIb%2Fymg5JLSJkyJFRUkDEtATEpUoiCNyHCexcGzLdmhQlP%2FOO7OzaycupVckfGjj9e7szOx8PNsOmtfXk8eiZuB7rvySujagJ4PJS0mqd2X%2BwA1PZ5vOscq7eWYAKjEIUcy9XtaL%2FJ0fxocpXQ30NUWe4zSntArTKrajR%2FvPrUAmIUJ%2BYhVXa51iXeT3TDJOOBTaObUVIqtMwJteXs4wwpnQaBrXXGeYfGSdV2aRg0zCrCNHJ2C2%2FuqIRBV9H6LWszxbV9vaaFy1GmC%2FX8r3pnn3ywFdjcfjlxDrhXsSUpkHpZtjS7iMqPGN2XY9UbKivj9vm1f8jC7koQ93t%2FefvtC3u88fyQ5djHSKbdpqWF%2B0Eo945%2FXl7NxGRGeiWeb9uVBghpcYcNM9OTX5%2FugW%2Fis7xkWCOukPWQsyVm40Rbi0Bzwp9jP6vkJ5Hj7EyXpT85mnyxnJUIUegRi9xiTTpOztvhComgI6uIda0iagExjjxhLxmy2SI0ErvhnpgHBFRXVuY1T4RRDaAlhALgIrMCAgJtqEGb7a5M3yHq%2Fs%2FYqrHi13wuir8AewCc06gvMCX0CY%2F%2F9q8Ra4lWTDRQ7Nt7BwzINPmPy14h17EgE9GFChuflYxPEwqkC%2FBRgKfBDt0qJM6oCU00Yo7UpsUY6FzGGgE78eKyGCMV78CjEb9O%2B8fL5Rr8QAcHMB2EENSWO2B3%2BHy6S0wIYrUJ7uttmM1mHhTAYFrLOhoJZdNcTNp6xnCIIS1Q%2BCiz0B7JIlvYiiyDlOl7ccJNcvW9IOTc4dTzTXWb646ERXS96SwfEampLJctNZaqPMvyPN0ZTnxg6b1ri7PcxP5XN%2BuMffhQ6nydZJaC60Ptns4ypsUwAk%2B9ri9XJ2KjXalVUOjxoB47g0rvKrSkUYJTXO7twp42ACl%2Fg%2BIZuBVPla1OzZ%2BIk0HRvHuZtwN5iaDvsfi%2F5JLPoN

from qwik.