Just a question, would it be possible if I send you the source code of the api i used

This appears to be what we already do. As discussed in <a class="iss

JAKIM Prayers Time,about batoulapps/adhan-js

Comments (20)

z3bi commented on June 22, 2024 1

location specific times that use calculations(more accurate)

You mean provide like list of location with their coordinates instead of automatically using their current location right?

No, calculating based on the user's exact coordinates are more accurate Islamically even if they are different from the published timetables. Consider that the government needs to provide a prayer time for an entire city, but on the eastern part of the city the sun sets at 5:01 PM and on the western side of the city the sun sets at 5:02 PM. The government might publish 5:02 PM for the entire city, but actually for people on the eastern side thats not the actual time of sunset.

These are the kinds of tweaks that the government is doing by hand that we may simply never be able to replicate in any kind of calculation.

from adhan-js.

z3bi commented on June 22, 2024

Yes would love to see it. As long as its doing calculation and not just using a fixed timetable that would be extremely helpful.

from adhan-js.

farisfaisalthena commented on June 22, 2024

https://github.com/kayrules/solatjakim-api-site. not sure if this is helpful but i will find more if there nothing here

from adhan-js.

z3bi commented on June 22, 2024

It looks like this is just downloading the prayer times from e-solat.gov.my. Sorry but for this library we are focusing on calculation based approaches.

from adhan-js.

farisfaisalthena commented on June 22, 2024

Can I know what kind of calculation is required because i did some findings and found this https://www.qiblaplus.com/prayertimes.html but not sure how helpful it is

from adhan-js.

z3bi commented on June 22, 2024

This appears to be what we already do.

As discussed in #43 now that we have added the updated rounding, you should have accurate JAKIM prayer times. If you want to match the government issued timetable you just need to use the same coordinates they use. Is there anything else you're looking for?

from adhan-js.

farisfaisalthena commented on June 22, 2024

Because the times are not accurate especially for Subuh. Please note that the left is from JAKIm and right is from the library. Although as mentioned before that mostly is just one or two minutes early, I have received a few feedback saying that having a accurate time is ideal as the app will be relied on if a particular user goes to a new place and does not know the time. I have also tested the coordinates from the compiled locations below

Subuh - 5:53 AM - 5:43 AM -> 10 Minutes Early
Zohor - 1:19 AM - 1:18 PM -> 1 Minute Early
Asar - 4:45 PM - 4:44 PM -> 1 Minute Early
Maghrib - 7:28 PM - 7:26 PM -> 2 Minutes Early
Isyak - 8.44 PM - 8:42 PM -> 2 Minutes Early

export const locations = [
  { category: 'Johor', code: 'JHR01', location: 'Pulau Aur', latitude: '2.444152', longitude: '104.524746' },
  { category: 'Johor', code: 'JHR01', location: 'Pemanggil', latitude: '2.580882', longitude: '104.326827' },
  { category: 'Johor', code: 'JHR02', location: 'Kota Tinggi', latitude: '1.729375', longitude: '103.899227' },
  { category: 'Johor', code: 'JHR02', location: 'Mersing', latitude: '2.430917', longitude: '103.836115' },
  { category: 'Johor', code: 'JHR02', location: 'Johor Bahru', latitude: '1.492659', longitude: '103.741359' },
  { category: 'Johor', code: 'JHR03', location: 'Kluang', latitude: '2.030068', longitude: '103.318464' },
  { category: 'Johor', code: 'JHR03', location: 'Pontian', latitude: '1.485561', longitude: '103.387859' },
  { category: 'Johor', code: 'JHR04', location: 'Batu Pahat', latitude: '1.849442', longitude: '102.928834' },
  { category: 'Johor', code: 'JHR04', location: 'Muar', latitude: '2.048817', longitude: '102.571553' },
  { category: 'Johor', code: 'JHR04', location: 'Segamat', latitude: '2.503460', longitude: '102.820754' },
  { category: 'Johor', code: 'JHR04', location: 'Gemas', latitude: '2.581593', longitude: '102.612488' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH01', location: 'Kota Setar', latitude: '6.096953', longitude: '100.353977' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH01', location: 'Kubang Pasu', latitude: '6.267335', longitude: '100.425831' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH01', location: 'Pokok Sena', latitude: '6.167317', longitude: '100.519358' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH02', location: 'Pendang', latitude: '5.993039', longitude: '100.477339' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH02', location: 'Kuala Muda', latitude: '5.644561', longitude: '100.489023' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH02', location: 'Yan', latitude: '5.794950', longitude: '100.372658' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH03', location: 'Padang Terap', latitude: '6.256764', longitude: '100.611034' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH03', location: 'Sik', latitude: '5.818345', longitude: '100.743021' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH04', location: 'Baling', latitude: '5.675547', longitude: '100.916814' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH05', location: 'Kulim', latitude: '5.371742', longitude: '100.555337' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH05', location: 'Bandar Bahru', latitude: '5.131163', longitude: '100.495534' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH06', location: 'Langkawi', latitude: '6.350000', longitude: '99.800000' },
  { category: 'Kedah', code: 'KDH07', location: 'Gunung Jerai', latitude: '5.783333', longitude: '100.433333' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN01', location: 'Kota Bahru', latitude: '6.116786', longitude: '102.277684' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN01', location: 'Bachok', latitude: '6.069586', longitude: '102.397185' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN01', location: 'Pasir Puteh', latitude: '5.836163', longitude: '102.407741' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN01', location: 'Tumpat', latitude: '6.199069', longitude: '102.169372' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN01', location: 'Pasir Mas', latitude: '6.042412', longitude: '102.142782' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN01', location: 'Tanah Merah', latitude: '5.808887', longitude: '102.147077' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN01', location: 'Machang', latitude: '5.767933', longitude: '102.215387' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN01', location: 'Kuala Krai', latitude: '5.530813', longitude: '102.201851' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN01', location: 'Mukim Chiku', latitude: '4.916993', longitude: '102.177656' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN03', location: 'Jeli', latitude: '5.700699', longitude: '101.843151' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN03', location: 'Gua Musang', latitude: '4.884279', longitude: '101.968178' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN03', location: 'Mukim Galas', latitude: '4.828924', longitude: '101.934807' },
  { category: 'Kelantan', code: 'KTN03', location: 'Bertam', latitude: '5.151936', longitude: '102.043792' },
  { category: 'Melaka', code: 'MLK01', location: 'Bandar Melaka', latitude: '2.197138', longitude: '102.249070' },
  { category: 'Melaka', code: 'MLK01', location: 'Alor Gajah', latitude: '2.382211', longitude: '102.211561' },
  { category: 'Melaka', code: 'MLK01', location: 'Jasin', latitude: '2.311337', longitude: '102.430923' },
  { category: 'Melaka', code: 'MLK01', location: 'Masjid Tanah', latitude: '2.352279', longitude: '102.108926' },
  { category: 'Melaka', code: 'MLK01', location: 'Merlimau', latitude: '2.145214', longitude: '102.422383' },
  { category: 'Melaka', code: 'MLK01', location: 'Nyalas', latitude: '2.436091', longitude: '102.469871' },
  { category: 'Negeri Sembilan', code: 'NGS01', location: 'Jempol', latitude: '2.896577', longitude: '102.405454' },
  { category: 'Negeri Sembilan', code: 'NGS01', location: 'Tampin', latitude: '2.472971', longitude: '102.231194' },
  { category: 'Negeri Sembilan', code: 'NGS02', location: 'Port Dickson', latitude: '2.522540', longitude: '101.796293' },
  { category: 'Negeri Sembilan', code: 'NGS02', location: 'Seremban', latitude: '2.725889', longitude: '101.937824' },
  { category: 'Negeri Sembilan', code: 'NGS02', location: 'Kuala Pilah', latitude: '2.740474', longitude: '102.248872' },
  { category: 'Negeri Sembilan', code: 'NGS02', location: 'Jelebu', latitude: '2.941072', longitude: '102.071910' },
  { category: 'Negeri Sembilan', code: 'NGS02', location: 'Rembau', latitude: '2.590525', longitude: '102.092986' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG01', location: 'Pulau Tioman', latitude: '2.790249', longitude: '104.169846' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG02', location: 'Kuantan', latitude: '3.816667', longitude: '103.333333' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG02', location: 'Pekan', latitude: '3.492095', longitude: '103.389545' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG02', location: 'Rompin', latitude: '2.688626', longitude: '102.522802' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG02', location: 'Muadzam Shah', latitude: '3.056192', longitude: '103.085225' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG03', location: 'Maran', latitude: '3.583380', longitude: '102.779065' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG03', location: 'Chenor', latitude: '3.493743', longitude: '102.581850' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG03', location: 'Temerloh', latitude: '3.448649', longitude: '102.416348' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG03', location: 'Bera', latitude: '3.270526', longitude: '102.453864' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG03', location: 'Jerantut', latitude: '3.937395', longitude: '102.362038' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG04', location: 'Bentong', latitude: '3.522168', longitude: '101.910353' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG04', location: 'Raub', latitude: '3.793532', longitude: '101.857465' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG04', location: 'Kuala Lipis', latitude: '4.184330', longitude: '102.054232' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG05', location: 'Genting Sempah', latitude: '3.350000', longitude: '101.783333' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG05', location: 'Janda Baik', latitude: '3.350000', longitude: '101.883333' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG05', location: 'Bukit Tinggi', latitude: '3.400997', longitude: '101.846822' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG06', location: 'Bukit Fraser', latitude: '3.711868', longitude: '101.736556' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG06', location: 'Genting Highlands', latitude: '3.423978', longitude: '101.793201' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG06', location: 'Cameron Highlands', latitude: '4.472120', longitude: '101.380144' },
  { category: 'Pahang', code: 'PHG03', location: 'Jengka', latitude: '3.723779', longitude: '102.545654' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK01', location: 'Tapah', latitude: '4.197730', longitude: '101.261529' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK01', location: 'Slim River', latitude: '3.830025', longitude: '101.404645' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK01', location: 'Tanjung Malim', latitude: '3.705842', longitude: '101.504916' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK02', location: 'Ipoh', latitude: '4.597479', longitude: '101.090106' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK02', location: 'Batu Gajah', latitude: '4.472081', longitude: '101.041240' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK02', location: 'Kampar', latitude: '4.308504', longitude: '101.153653' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK02', location: 'Sungai Siput', latitude: '4.819012', longitude: '101.073718' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK02', location: 'Kuala Kangsar', latitude: '4.773595', longitude: '100.942045' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK03', location: 'Pengkalan Hulu', latitude: '5.706440', longitude: '100.999837' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK03', location: 'Grik', latitude: '5.428454', longitude: '101.129703' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK03', location: 'Lenggong', latitude: '5.108440', longitude: '100.968034' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK04', location: 'Temengor', latitude: '5.333186', longitude: '101.367712' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK04', location: 'Belum', latitude: '5.740126', longitude: '101.479350' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK05', location: 'Teluk Intan', latitude: '4.022424', longitude: '101.020625' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK05', location: 'Bagan Datuk', latitude: '3.991910', longitude: '100.786148' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK05', location: 'Kampung Gajah', latitude: '4.184167', longitude: '100.938719' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK05', location: 'Seri Iskandar', latitude: '4.357145', longitude: '100.963392' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK05', location: 'Beruas', latitude: '4.500804', longitude: '100.781508' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK05', location: 'Parit', latitude: '4.476689', longitude: '100.909749' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK05', location: 'Lumut', latitude: '4.236302', longitude: '100.632220' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK05', location: 'Sitiawan', latitude: '4.216825', longitude: '100.697824' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK05', location: 'Pulau Pangkor', latitude: '4.227491', longitude: '100.557741' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK06', location: 'Selama', latitude: '5.218462', longitude: '100.693460' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK06', location: 'Taiping', latitude: '4.851932', longitude: '100.741634' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK06', location: 'Bagan Serai', latitude: '5.008062', longitude: '100.539430' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK06', location: 'Parit Buntar', latitude: '5.118682', longitude: '100.488016' },
  { category: 'Perak', code: 'PRK07', location: 'Bukit Larut', latitude: '4.862300', longitude: '100.793000' },
  { category: 'Perlis', code: 'PLS01', location: 'Kangar', latitude: '6.440633', longitude: '100.198371' },
  { category: 'Perlis', code: 'PLS01', location: 'Padang Besar', latitude: '6.662622', longitude: '100.321665' },
  { category: 'Perlis', code: 'PLS01', location: 'Arau', latitude: '6.429708', longitude: '100.269847' },
  { category: 'Pulau Pinang', code: 'PNG01', location: 'Pulau Pinang', latitude: '5.414168', longitude: '100.328759' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH01', location: 'Sandakan Timur', latitude: '5.839444', longitude: '118.117173' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH01', location: 'Bukit Garam', latitude: '5.500122', longitude: '117.837606' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH01', location: 'Semawang', latitude: '5.916667', longitude: '117.766666' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH01', location: 'Temanggong', latitude: '4.910632', longitude: '114.934834' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH01', location: 'Tambisan', latitude: '5.450148', longitude: '119.109986' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH02', location: 'Pinangah', latitude: '4.990731', longitude: '116.832411' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH02', location: 'Terusan', latitude: '6.426081', longitude: '117.687599' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH02', location: 'Beluran', latitude: '5.702070', longitude: '117.401544' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH02', location: 'Kuamut', latitude: '5.015856', longitude: '117.353107' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH02', location: 'Telupid', latitude: '5.627233', longitude: '117.127534' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH03', location: 'Lahad Datu', latitude: '5.024206', longitude: '118.330746' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH03', location: 'Kunak', latitude: '4.686116', longitude: '118.251146' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH03', location: 'Silabukan', latitude: '5.136667', longitude: '118.614167' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH03', location: 'Tungku', latitude: '4.931209', longitude: '114.911622' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH03', location: 'Sahabat', latitude: '5.078867', longitude: '119.070775' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH03', location: 'Semporna', latitude: '4.479391', longitude: '118.611545' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH04', location: 'Bandar Tawau', latitude: '4.244651', longitude: '117.891186' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH04', location: 'Balong', latitude: '4.398421', longitude: '118.058604' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH04', location: 'Merotai', latitude: '4.356929', longitude: '117.827169' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH04', location: 'Kalabakan', latitude: '4.411679', longitude: '117.492699' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH05', location: 'Kudat', latitude: '6.886840', longitude: '116.825311' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH05', location: 'Kota Marudu', latitude: '6.465705', longitude: '116.726409' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH05', location: 'Pitas', latitude: '6.722237', longitude: '117.055273' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH05', location: 'Pulau Banggi', latitude: '7.267260', longitude: '117.150005' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH06', location: 'Gunung Kinabalu', latitude: '6.074544', longitude: '116.562720' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH07', location: 'Papar', latitude: '5.734628', longitude: '115.931851' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH07', location: 'Ranau', latitude: '5.953561', longitude: '116.663950' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH07', location: 'Kota Belud', latitude: '6.353248', longitude: '116.427877' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH07', location: 'Tuaran', latitude: '6.176269', longitude: '116.232790' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH07', location: 'Penampang', latitude: '5.914199', longitude: '116.107663' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH07', location: 'Kota Kinabalu', latitude: '5.980408', longitude: '116.073457' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH08', location: 'Pensiangan', latitude: '4.550000', longitude: '116.316667' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH08', location: 'Keningau', latitude: '5.337404', longitude: '116.156680' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH08', location: 'Tambunan', latitude: '5.721291', longitude: '116.410779' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH08', location: 'Nabawan', latitude: '5.122208', longitude: '116.432583' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH09', location: 'Sipitang', latitude: '5.079190', longitude: '115.550825' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH09', location: 'Membakut', latitude: '5.527729', longitude: '115.695961' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH09', location: 'Beaufort', latitude: '5.345118', longitude: '115.745112' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH09', location: 'Kuala Penyu', latitude: '5.571717', longitude: '115.597146' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH09', location: 'Weston', latitude: '5.216881', longitude: '115.598801' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH09', location: 'Tenom', latitude: '5.130495', longitude: '115.945455' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH09', location: 'Long Pa Sia', latitude: '5.978840', longitude: '116.075320' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH01', location: 'Sukau', latitude: '5.551318', longitude: '118.302786' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH02', location: 'Sandakan Barat', latitude: '5.814070', longitude: '117.732406' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH03', location: 'Tawau Timur', latitude: '4.451914', longitude: '118.169232' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH04', location: 'Tawau Barat', latitude: '4.487002', longitude: '117.307201' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH07', location: 'Putatan', latitude: '5.876932', longitude: '116.058926' },
  { category: 'Sabah', code: 'SBH07', location: 'Pantai Barat', latitude: '6.083333', longitude: '116.500000' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK01', location: 'Limbang', latitude: '4.755032', longitude: '115.008146' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK01', location: 'Sundar', latitude: '4.887442', longitude: '115.226701' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK01', location: 'Terusan', latitude: '4.283333', longitude: '115.616666' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK01', location: 'Lawas', latitude: '4.834950', longitude: '115.393738' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK02', location: 'Niah', latitude: '3.866516', longitude: '113.730859' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK02', location: 'Belaga', latitude: '3.200278', longitude: '113.934714' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK02', location: 'Sibuti', latitude: '4.045211', longitude: '113.799896' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK02', location: 'Miri', latitude: '4.399493', longitude: '113.991383' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK02', location: 'Bekenu', latitude: '4.058185', longitude: '113.844193' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK02', location: 'Marudi', latitude: '4.406340', longitude: '114.262830' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK03', location: 'Song', latitude: '2.006440', longitude: '112.549760' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK03', location: 'Balingian', latitude: '2.930870', longitude: '112.539540' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK03', location: 'Sebauh', latitude: '3.063030', longitude: '113.477610' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK03', location: 'Bintulu', latitude: '3.171322', longitude: '113.041907' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK03', location: 'Tatau', latitude: '2.878960', longitude: '112.855621' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK03', location: 'Kapit', latitude: '1.995115', longitude: '112.933085' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK04', location: 'Igan', latitude: '2.823991', longitude: '111.710899' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK04', location: 'Kanowit', latitude: '2.101223', longitude: '112.153298' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK04', location: 'Sibu', latitude: '2.287284', longitude: '111.830535' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK04', location: 'Dalat', latitude: '2.666667', longitude: '112.083333' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK04', location: 'Oya', latitude: '2.858436', longitude: '111.875922' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK05', location: 'Belawai', latitude: '2.220691', longitude: '111.218333' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK05', location: 'Matu', latitude: '2.695497', longitude: '111.471668' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK05', location: 'Daro', latitude: '2.527996', longitude: '111.417057' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK05', location: 'Sarikei', latitude: '2.131703', longitude: '111.523728' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK05', location: 'Julau', latitude: '2.024275', longitude: '111.916609' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK05', location: 'Bitangor', latitude: '2.169966', longitude: '111.636641' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK05', location: 'Rajang', latitude: '2.137227', longitude: '111.224885' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK06', location: 'Kabong', latitude: '1.803557', longitude: '111.130108' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK06', location: 'Lingga', latitude: '1.250000', longitude: '111.166666' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK06', location: 'Sri Aman', latitude: '1.237031', longitude: '111.462079' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK06', location: 'Engkelili', latitude: '1.138464', longitude: '111.666259' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK06', location: 'Betong', latitude: '1.411517', longitude: '111.528999' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK06', location: 'Spaoh', latitude: '1.462578', longitude: '111.479364' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK06', location: 'Pusa', latitude: '1.619999', longitude: '111.291599' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK06', location: 'Saratok', latitude: '1.738795', longitude: '111.337840' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK06', location: 'Roban', latitude: '1.866759', longitude: '111.334493' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK06', location: 'Debak', latitude: '1.562670', longitude: '111.422177' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK07', location: 'Samarahan', latitude: '1.442757', longitude: '110.497711' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK07', location: 'Simunjan', latitude: '1.072972', longitude: '110.915332' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK07', location: 'Serian', latitude: '1.167035', longitude: '110.566506' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK07', location: 'Sebuyau', latitude: '1.396803', longitude: '111.071899' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK07', location: 'Meludam', latitude: '1.476546', longitude: '111.213336' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK08', location: 'Kuching', latitude: '1.560000', longitude: '110.345000' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK08', location: 'Bau', latitude: '1.417224', longitude: '110.154629' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK08', location: 'Lundu', latitude: '1.671364', longitude: '109.851969' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK08', location: 'Sematan', latitude: '1.807459', longitude: '109.775842' },
  { category: 'Sarawak', code: 'SWK09', location: 'Zon Khas', latitude: '4.962580', longitude: '115.554338' },
  { category: 'Selangor', code: 'SGR01', location: 'Gombak', latitude: '3.253502', longitude: '101.653326' },
  { category: 'Selangor', code: 'SGR01', location: 'Hulu Selangor', latitude: '3.560105', longitude: '101.658312' },
  { category: 'Selangor', code: 'SGR01', location: 'Rawang', latitude: '3.320482', longitude: '101.575924' },
  { category: 'Selangor', code: 'SGR01', location: 'Hulu Langat', latitude: '3.113117', longitude: '101.815673' },
  { category: 'Selangor', code: 'SGR01', location: 'Sepang', latitude: '2.691369', longitude: '101.750527' },
  { category: 'Selangor', code: 'SGR01', location: 'Petaling', latitude: '3.083333', longitude: '101.583333' },
  { category: 'Selangor', code: 'SGR01', location: 'Shah Alam', latitude: '3.073281', longitude: '101.518461' },
  { category: 'Selangor', code: 'SGR02', location: 'Sabak Bernam', latitude: '3.678777', longitude: '100.990592' },
  { category: 'Selangor', code: 'SGR02', location: 'Kuala Selangor', latitude: '3.340184', longitude: '101.249762' },
  { category: 'Selangor', code: 'SGR03', location: 'Klang', latitude: '3.044917', longitude: '101.445562' },
  { category: 'Selangor', code: 'SGR03', location: 'Kuala Langat', latitude: '2.803828', longitude: '101.495070' },
  { category: 'Terengganu', code: 'TRG01', location: 'Kuala Terengganu', latitude: '5.329624', longitude: '103.137014' },
  { category: 'Terengganu', code: 'TRG01', location: 'Marang', latitude: '5.207711', longitude: '103.204944' },
  { category: 'Terengganu', code: 'TRG02', location: 'Besut', latitude: '5.829012', longitude: '102.552378' },
  { category: 'Terengganu', code: 'TRG02', location: 'Setiu', latitude: '5.443798', longitude: '102.825218' },
  { category: 'Terengganu', code: 'TRG03', location: 'Hulu Terengganu', latitude: '5.073042', longitude: '103.008937' },
  { category: 'Terengganu', code: 'TRG04', location: 'Kemaman', latitude: '4.777790', longitude: '103.033887' },
  { category: 'Terengganu', code: 'TRG04', location: 'Dungun', latitude: '4.777790', longitude: '103.033887' },
  { category: 'Terengganu', code: 'TRG01', location: 'Kuala Nerus', latitude: '5.333333', longitude: '103.000000' },
  { category: 'Putrajaya', code: 'WLY01', location: 'Putrajaya', latitude: '2.926361', longitude: '101.696445' },
  { category: 'Kuala Lumpur', code: 'WLY01', location: 'Kuala Lumpur', latitude: '3.139003', longitude: '101.686855' },
  { category: 'Labuan', code: 'WLY02', location: 'Labuan', latitude: '5.275346', longitude: '115.247346' },
];

from adhan-js.

farisfaisalthena commented on June 22, 2024

Because as alternative if the detection of current location coordinates does not work i will let users choose this location above and use the coordinates if its accurate also

from adhan-js.

farisfaisalthena commented on June 22, 2024

https://github.com/zulfahmi93/dart-libpray

from adhan-js.

z3bi commented on June 22, 2024

https://github.com/zulfahmi93/dart-libpray

Does this library produce times closer to the published times you are comparing against?

from adhan-js.

farisfaisalthena commented on June 22, 2024

Actually for this particular one i have not tested but if you want to test this after implementing like that I could help you

from adhan-js.

z3bi commented on June 22, 2024

For the 10 minute difference in subuh that is because they appear to be using Imsak as the Fajr time? It seems though you can just add 10 minutes to replicate their subuh time.

Aside from that, differences of 1-2 minutes is almost unavoidable. Published timetable used by governments are often "hand tweaked" and can't be replicated by calculation alone.

As an app developer you can either offer location specific times that use calculations (more accurate) or you can choose to present published timetables. Asking a calculation library to replicate a timetable exactly is simply not feasible. It seems perhaps you simply want to offer the exact timetable published by the Malaysian government and that is not something this library will have as a feature.

from adhan-js.

farisfaisalthena commented on June 22, 2024

location specific times that use calculations(more accurate)

You mean provide like list of location with their coordinates instead of automatically using their current location right?

from adhan-js.

korbav commented on June 22, 2024

@farisfaisalthena Are you located in Malaysia?
If so, could you confirm (or not) whether JAKIM is only used in Malaysia (or is it also used in other countries like Indonesia)?
If it's only used in Malaysia, and because the areas definition is fixed and finite, then referring to the sandbox I did some days ago, it might be a good to reconsider its implementation https://codesandbox.io/s/wild-voice-xo7fd.

However, there's a big warning even if we'd dive into that, as said @z3bi , and also as explicitly written in https://www.e-solat.gov.my :

Which means that, potentially, there are as many tweaks/slightly different calculation methods as the number of states in Malaysia, it's clearly impossible to be 100% accurate, and even if we would, there would be no guarantee to stay sync over the time (for example if a mufti would be replaced by another one who would change the state's calculation method).

from adhan-js.

farisfaisalthena commented on June 22, 2024

@korbav hi yeah im located in malaysia. I am also sure that JAKIM is also used in Indonesia https://www.muslimpro.com/Prayer-times-Indonesia-ID?date=&convention=JAKIM

from adhan-js.

korbav commented on June 22, 2024

@korbav hi yeah im located in malaysia. I am also sure that JAKIM is also used in Indonesia https://www.muslimpro.com/Prayer-times-Indonesia-ID?date=&convention=JAKIM

Great, I think at this point, we need to collect verified information about what is happening behind the scene with the calculations, how is it being spread over the different countries, which areas are concerned, what kind of tweaks are being done etc..

From my perspective, the most benefical now is that you contact directly JAKIM institute (in Malay) to get strong information/documents we can base ourselves on.

After that, we will be able to have a better analyzis and to take a decision if there is an interest / a possibility / a pertinency to implement something.

from adhan-js.

farisfaisalthena commented on June 22, 2024

From my perspective, the most benefical now is that you contact directly JAKIM institute (in Malay) to get strong information/documents we can base ourselves on.

Sure thing! Would it be possible if you let me know the questions you need so I dont miss any questions or another option I can provide you the email of JAKIM

from adhan-js.

farisfaisalthena commented on June 22, 2024

it might be a good to reconsider its implementation https://codesandbox.io/s/wild-voice-xo7fd.

I did tested it but unfortunately the time gets earlier compared to the current implementation

from adhan-js.

korbav commented on June 22, 2024

it might be a good to reconsider its implementation https://codesandbox.io/s/wild-voice-xo7fd.

I did tested it but unfortunately the time gets earlier compared to the current implementation

From my perspective, the most benefical now is that you contact directly JAKIM institute (in Malay) to get strong information/documents we can base ourselves on.

Sure thing! Would it be possible if you let me know the questions you need so I dont miss any questions or another option I can provide you the email of JAKIM

I would say (it's also necessary to wait the input of @z3bi which will be more concise!) :

In which countries is JAKIM method being used?
Is JAKIM method being used the same way wherever it's used (ie. in all the countries where it's used) ?
Are the geographical areas defined by the JAKIM fixed or subject to change?
Which degrees of liberty are given to the states using this method? (ie. what kind of choices are left to the muftis?)
Do we have a clear list of the tweaks in the different states? is it subject to change over the time / mufti replacements?
Can we have a technical documentation of the algorithm/parameters being used?
/Or Can we have a concise overview of the method?

That's it for me, I don't see anything else but please also wait for @z3bi 's input before contacting JAKIM.

from adhan-js.

z3bi commented on June 22, 2024

In terms of contacting JAKIM, any official explanation on how they arrive at their prayer times would be a good starting point. Once we have that I think we can decide from there.

from adhan-js.

JAKIM Prayers Time about adhan-js HOT 20 CLOSED

Comments (20)

Related Issues (20)

Recommend Projects

React

Vue.js

Typescript

TensorFlow

Django

Laravel

D3

Recommend Topics

javascript

web

server

Machine learning

Visualization

Game

Recommend Org

Facebook

Microsoft

Google

Alibaba

D3

Tencent