UI Comments on the Records Page about trusted-setup-frontend HOT 6 CLOSED

Hey @tvanepps! Almost finish here 🚀. Meanwhile, I add some comments to your observations

2. The sequencer signs and sends a receipt after the participant uploads the contribution. We can use the sequencer address to confirm that the receipt was truly coming from the sequencer itself.

3. We were thinking on showing the participants their 4 PoT pubkeys right away because these are like their unique fingerprints in the contribution. We should the identicons in the completed contribution modal and here. The color combination make them unique and it is a nice way to showing how every single contribution is unique in the list.

7.1. I voted on leaving the identicons outside and inside the modal.
7.2. We can put them in a 4x1 array

9. Right now the sequencer is in development mode and it is accepting multiple contributions from the same participant

10. The first audit report was related to the Small Powers of Tau implementation. We decided to swap that implementation with the sequencer crypto library (which was already audited in the second report). I feel we can leave only one Audit Report link to the Sigma Prime audit PDF

from trusted-setup-frontend.

One other UI consideration: If you're on e.g. the second page of contributions, and then you search for a particular address, it won't show up until you click the "1" at the bottom to jump back to the first page, which confused me at first.

from trusted-setup-frontend.

Generally, it's hard to know what this modal is telling users - should they be saving the info locally? we should consider adding some tooltips next to each header 🛈 that expands with info on hover, or just include all info next to the header by default.

10. • the "x" appears differently when next to text vs a number
11. • "Pot" is not useful. Should either say "Powers of Tau" or be omitted
12. • Can we reproduce the identicons here next to their pubkey to show the link? if we do this, make sure the image is aligned with the left side of the header text above
13. • "Sequence #" (or whatever it's changed to on the screen before) should also appear on this modal below "Contribution Details" - possibly with ←→ toggle so users can cycle through many contributions without having to exit and reenter this modal every time. the toggle arrows are a lower priority tho

from trusted-setup-frontend.

14. • There should be a an action suggestion for each of the numbers/ arrow when i hover it should change to the hand cursor and be underlined/ drop shadowed
15. • the footer is just a little too large. can we shrink it vertically to about the size of the red rectangle?
16. • We will have 2 audit reports, maybe there needs to be separate links to the Implementation report and the sequencer audit? or just remove this link and send users to the documentation where they can find both
      

from trusted-setup-frontend.

thanks for the clarifications/info. these generally make sense

2. we probably need a guide for how users should verify contributions. see the namada trusted setup "Verify Contribution" button, instructions hosted on github. what would verification look like for our ceremony? eg. hosted on the interface itself vs. or another repo, what steps would the user need to complete, etc

3. makes sense. we might need a tooltip for this to explain why unique identicons are important / what they signify

4. makes sense, carl also explained why this is the case. we should definitely start with a clean slate when the time comes

5. sounds good, we will need to upload the completed report to the kzg repo when it's produced and point to that one

from trusted-setup-frontend.

The Signed by field is confusing. It shows the identity of the contributor, but it's under the title of 'Sequencer Acknowledgement' I feel it should show the sequencer's address, as proof that the real sequencer signed the receipt.

The contributor identity could also be shown on the page, but in a different place so it's clear it belongs to the contributor, not the sequencer.

from trusted-setup-frontend.