add self-hosted plan for self-hosted flavor about affine HOT 29 OPEN

the original intention of this issue is to "promote the repair of the self-hosted plan" rather than "what feature should self-hosted have?" or "what license should an open source project have?"
there are already too many off-topic discussions, i am here Mark all off-topic discussions as off-topic.

if you have any questions and discussions related to self-hosted, please go to: https://github.com/toeverything/AFFiNE/discussions to discuss

from affine.

It's not hard to figure out - the user_features table has a feature_id column which links the user to a specific plan, listed in the features table.
I have my users set to 6, which is the pro_plan_v1.

from affine.

Will self-host plan be a one-time fee?

Of course, it's free.

The self-host plan have unlimited storage space for free.

We may impose some limit on the number of collaborators to prevent enterprises from directly using the self-host version, as we hope to generate some revenue from business users. There will be no limit for personal use.

from affine.

Outline has a good pricing concept for a comparable product: https://www.getoutline.com/pricing

from affine.

Outline has a good pricing concept for a comparable product: https://www.getoutline.com/pricing

It is to second that the license used for Outline (BSL-1.1) with the terms supplied (1) allows unlimited usage for personal and not-for-profit use and (2) releases the source code under a free license after two years.

• https://github.com/outline/outline/blob/ceb7ae15142bba38b7107b7a19820dbb1d200300/LICENSE

This is a model that works very well to support the civic society, while allowing to constrain the usage on commercial vendors offering services based on the product. The dual licensing of freely releasing the client but enclosing the server to proprietary terms (https://github.com/toeverything/AFFiNE/blob/canary/packages/backend/server/LICENSE) breaks the collaboration model of free software, in which error reports and triaging are contributed back to upstream, because we know it benefits others.

I would like to suggest to consider fine-tuning and adopting the current licensing approach with regards to personal and not-for-profit use cases that benefit society as a whole, but not only the sole proprietor of the product.

from affine.

Upcoming in: v0.14.0

We've got great news! 🚀 This issue's fix/feature is slated for release in AFFiNE v0.14.0.
Subscribe to this issue for a notification when the release goes live!

^{_{This is an automatic reply by the bot.}}

from affine.

Issue Status: 💡 Open

💡 Open

We want to implement the fix or feature in the near future. We can’t promise it will appear in the next public release, but it’s on our short list.

^{_{This is an automatic reply by the bot.}}

from affine.

Will self-host plan be a one-time fee?

from affine.

Will self-host plan be a one-time fee?

@greedyhao I am not sure what is your question. Do you mean if there is a license charge fee for self-hosting?

from affine.

Will self-host plan be a one-time fee?

Of course, it's free.

The self-host plan have unlimited storage space for free.

We may impose some limit on the number of collaborators to prevent enterprises from directly using the self-host version, as we hope to generate some revenue from business users. There will be no limit for personal use.

Thanks a lot. That's what I want to know.

from affine.

Will self-host plan be a one-time fee?

Of course, it's free.

The self-host plan have unlimited storage space for free.

We may impose some limit on the number of collaborators to prevent enterprises from directly using the self-host version, as we hope to generate some revenue from business users. There will be no limit for personal use.

This reads a bit contradictory to the comment made in the related discussion. Are you saying that hobbyists, non-commercial users will have no limitation on collaboratiors per space and globally and storage?

from affine.

Will self-host plan be a one-time fee?

Of course, it's free.
The self-host plan have unlimited storage space for free.
We may impose some limit on the number of collaborators to prevent enterprises from directly using the self-host version, as we hope to generate some revenue from business users. There will be no limit for personal use.

This reads a bit contradictory to the comment made in the related discussion. Are you saying that hobbyists, non-commercial users will have no limitation on collaboratiors per space and globally and storage?

collaborators always have seat limits

from affine.

Ok, let me rephrase it: Will the space owner on a self-hosted install without a commercial usage be restricted in the number of people they can invite to participate in a space? Currently that limit is three.

from affine.

Ok, let me rephrase it: Will the space owner on a self-hosted install without a commercial usage be restricted in the number of people they can invite to participate in a space? Currently that limit is three.

tldr, will. however, it needs to be emphasized that "seats" are currently equivalent to "people who can access the whole workspace" and "people who can collaborate together in the workspace", but in the future, we will support sharing a single doc and allow you to edit and collaborate it with others that not in seats. in this case, the collaborators of single doc will not be limited by the number of seats.

this feature is not yet implemented, but we will support it in a future version.

from affine.

Ok, let me rephrase it: Will the space owner on a self-hosted install without a commercial usage be restricted in the number of people they can invite to participate in a space? Currently that limit is three.

tldr, will. however, it needs to be emphasized that "seats" are currently equivalent to "people who can access the whole workspace" and "people who can collaborate together in the workspace", but in the future, we will support sharing a single doc and allow you to edit and collaborate it with others that not in seats. in this case, the collaborators of single doc will not be limited by the number of seats.

this feature is not yet implemented, but we will support it in a future version.

Hello !
Thank you very much for the self-hosted version. This is much appreciated.
I'm not sure I fully understand the comment.
I'm ready to install Affine on my homelab.
This is aimed as being our family wiki where we can all access and edit information.
Will that be possible or should I disown 2 of my children 😅 ?

from affine.

Hello ! Thank you very much for the self-hosted version. This is much appreciated. I'm not sure I fully understand the comment. I'm ready to install Affine on my homelab. This is aimed as being our family wiki where we can all access and edit information. Will that be possible or should I disown 2 of my children 😅 ?

we will support purchasing seats in a future version, so stay tuned

from affine.

And purchasing will be required no matter the usage of a self-hosted install? aka private/hobbyist/non-commercial usage?
Do you have a cost estimate and will it be a one time fee or subscriprion?

from affine.

And purchasing will be required no matter the usage of a self-hosted install? aka private/hobbyist/non-commercial usage? Do you have a cost estimate and will it be a one time fee or subscriprion?

once the relevant details are confirmed, we will release it on our official media account and blog, please stay tuned

from affine.

For example, Apple allows iCloud to be shared between 6 family members 🙏 (for private use only).

from affine.

For example, Apple allows iCloud to be shared between 6 family members 🙏 (for private use only).

the current pro plan of AFFiNE Cloud supports collaboration with 10 people

from affine.

Outline has a good pricing concept for a comparable product: https://www.getoutline.com/pricing

thank you for your suggestion, we will refer to the relevant information

from affine.

I was planning to move from outline (outline free plan cannot create workspace) to affine, but after installation, I found that the license plan is connected to the cloud. I gave up and returned to notion. Notion’s 8 USD plan can add 100 guests, if it is not unlimited of users (EX: <500) affine self-hosting is not competitive

from affine.

I was planning to move from outline (outline free plan cannot create workspace) to affine, but after installation, I found that the license plan is connected to the cloud. I gave up and returned to notion. Notion’s 8 USD plan can add 100 guests, if it is not unlimited of users (EX: <500) affine self-hosting is not competitive

According to the definition of Notion, the user who can edit the entire Workspace is Member. Guest specifically refers to a user who can edit a certain page.

At present, AFFiNE does not have a single-page collaboration feature for the time being, so it cannot be compared with this number.

The single-page collaboration feature will be launched later this year. Please follow our social media accounts and blogs.

from affine.

Since there's unclear communication and diverging information regarding licensing, I will go back to Nextcloud Collectives and outline for the moment. Sad, because this looks promising, but claiming it's fully open source* when it isn't and free for self-hosting when it isn't** is a bit of a deal-breaker.

Plus: All data is stored in a database in a custom format, Markdown is only possible via export. So the data cannot be transported that easily and can get lost, if the database crashes (looking at you, WordPress)

• in parts
  ** with strong limitations, which are not yet well-defined, but appear to become quite strict

from affine.

Hello, curious about is there progress on it? Is self host version can still only have three users in one workspace, and the space is limited to 10 GiB?

from affine.

Hello, curious about is there progress on it? Is self host version can still only have three users in one workspace, and the space is limited to 10 GiB?

You can set your users to be on the Pro plan manually in the database, which raises the limits.

from affine.

Hello, curious about is there progress on it? Is self host version can still only have three users in one workspace, and the space is limited to 10 GiB?

You can set your users to be on the Pro plan manually in the database, which raises the limits.

Thank you, I had connect to the self-host pg, would it be convenient to share which table has the field for pro? thank you

from affine.

It's not hard to figure out - the user_features table has a feature_id column which links the user to a specific plan, listed in the features table. I have my users set to 6, which is the pro_plan_v1.

Thank you, save my day!

from affine.

from

seems that even with pro_plan_v1, memberLimit is set to 10, maybe I should package an image my self

NO need for a new docker image

The correct feature_id for user_features is in table features, which may look like

docker exec -it affine_postgres psql -U affine

affine=# select id, feature, configs from features where feature = 'pro_plan_v1';
 id |   feature   |                                                    configs                                                    
----+-------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  6 | pro_plan_v1 | {"name":"Pro","blobLimit":104857600,"storageQuota":107374182400,"historyPeriod":2592000000,"memberLimit":100}
 11 | pro_plan_v1 | {"name":"Pro","blobLimit":104857600,"storageQuota":107374182400,"historyPeriod":2592000000,"memberLimit":100}
(2 rows)

in the configs, update JSON to one with larger memberLimit is enough.

after that, reboot the docker compose

from affine.