Quests for opening hours are also asked for zoo=enclosure marked as a zoo, within a zoo about streetcomplete HOT 8 CLOSED

The tag zoo=enclosure is used to describe a type of zoo (tagged with tourism=zoo) where the animals are kept in enclosures or cages.

So it should not be used on individual enclosures.

Later there is

Part of zoo fits this description
Create an area inside tourism=zoo and tag it zoo=enclosure.

Note that it has "Create an area inside tourism=zoo and tag it zoo=enclosure." without mention of tagging it also tourism=zoo.

Maybe "do not tag it tourism=zoo in such case" should be explicitly mentioned there and general description should mention using it to tag individual enclosures?

And either way, no matter what https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:zoo%3Denclosure would say, tagging part of zoo as entire zoo would be wrong anyway.

I would be happy to discuss it more at tagging mailing list or official forum or OSM Wiki talk page - please leave here link if such discussion would be started.

from streetcomplete.

I also started https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Tag:zoo%3Denclosure#Part_of_zoo_fits_this_description_-_maybe_make_clear_that_part_of_zoo_should_not_be_tagged_as_a_zoo%3F

from streetcomplete.

Ways with the tags tourism=zoo and zoo=enclosure are included in the opening hours quest even if they are within a zoo.

If something is not a zoo and is tagged as tourism=zoo then it should be fixed in OpenStreetMap.

If there is zoo within zoo then SC should ask.

Opening hours quests are only asked for the zoo, not the enclosure.

They are. ("Ways with the tags tourism=zoo")

from streetcomplete.

In general, StreetComplete does not add elaborate filters to support handling of broken data.

Tagging something as tourism=zoo when it is not a zoo but part of it is wrong in the same way as tagging something as place=city but is actually a part of city.

from streetcomplete.

If something is not a zoo and is tagged as tourism=zoo then it should be fixed in OpenStreetMap.

Any enclosure should be tagged as tourism=zoo according to the wiki. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:zoo%3Denclosure

from streetcomplete.

Thanks for looking into this and discussing this. It makes sense to discuss this somewhere else.

from streetcomplete.

Possibly tourism=zoo is added because it's listed under Requires.
From the wiki page it's not clear though whether the Requires exclusively refers to the element tagged with zoo=enclosure, or to surrounding areas or maybe nearby nodes with tourism=zoo.

from streetcomplete.

That part was self contradictory with wiki page itself so I edited it.

from streetcomplete.