Inconsistent Decimal Mark Handling after CSV Import with Rules about hledger HOT 2 CLOSED

Thanks a lot for clarifying. I've just used only D directive. Commodity also specify style for reporting which is impressive.

Thank you for this remarkably beautiful and useful tool.

from hledger.

Thanks for reporting!

Is the behaviour explained and justified by this:

import tries to follow the journal's existing commodity styles when it creates new entries.
During the first import, the journal contains no thousand commas, so the style for $ is no commas.
During the second import, because of the one thousand comma you added to the journal, the style with thousand commas is inferred for $, and used for the new entry.

Either avoiding adding unwanted thousand commas in the journal, or declaring the desired style explicitly in the journal with

commodity $1000.00

will prevent it.

from hledger.