How to know if data is loading to display loading screen rather than login page? about react-firebase HOT 5 OPEN

the issue here appears to be the authState doesn't have a loading value. its probably no that difficult to add one in. did you want to work on a PR?

from react-firebase.

Yes I can work on it. But I don't get much free time so i'll be a slow a bit.

from react-firebase.

Just hit this issue and it's... not ideal. Seems like there is a semi official Google maintained React bindings lib here https://github.com/FirebaseExtended/reactfire which supports loading states but the docs are SO Google. Seems unfinished and hard to follow.

For now one way around it is to store the current user in local storage and simply redirect away from the login page if they exist there. Not the best solution, but better than rendering confusing UI in my opinion until this is resolved.

Edit: seems like @rakannimer is using https://github.com/csfrequency/react-firebase-hooks in his NextJs demo app which has a loading state provided through the useAuthState hook so it might be good to check that out as well

from react-firebase.

As a possible solution I created my own AuthProvider component which passes loading to children via render props

import { Component } from 'react';
import firebase from 'firebase/app';
import { func } from 'prop-types';

export class AuthProvider extends Component {
  state = {
    loading: firebase.auth().currentUser === null,
    user: firebase.auth().currentUser,
  };

  componentDidMount() {
    firebase
      .auth()
      .onAuthStateChanged(
        user => user && this.setState({ user, loading: false })
      );
  }

  render() {
    const { loading, user } = this.state;

    return this.props.children({ loading, user });
  }
}

AuthProvider.propTypes = {
  children: func,
};

That being said, I've migrated to using react-firebase-hooks as it seems to be a little more active

from react-firebase.

Just found this and it lines up with my own observations - it's impossible to know if the user is logged in instantly without using local storage https://stackoverflow.com/a/51856627/12128359. The firebase.auth().currentUser method is not instant, I guess it makes some sort of async call.

Probably an okay solution would be to wire in ways to store the user in local storage within a provider like this. That way you can easily mutate the value in local storage in the onAuthStateChanged observer callback and have it be accurate.

from react-firebase.