Bug hazard - multiple strings given same indentation about black HOT 2 OPEN

Yeah, I guess I deal with long lines a lot. The most recent use case where this came up was a bulleted list of sentences, so its much harder to notice when a bullet combines with a previous one.

Would happy if its just a config option. The fact its a bug hazard is why I am suggesting it just be the default behavior.

from black.

What you describe isn't actually Black's current style.

It will put all the strings on line because they're short enough:

% black -c '''some_func(
    "can you"
    "spot the bug",
    "in this list of strings",
    "where a comma is missing?" 
)
'''          
some_func(
    "can you" "spot the bug", "in this list of strings", "where a comma is missing?"
)

If you use the magic trailing comma to force each argument on its own line, the two implicitly concatenated strings are kept together, making it fairly clear that they belong together:

% black -c '''some_func(
    "can you"
    "spot the bug",
    "in this list of strings",
    "where a comma is missing?",
)
'''
some_func(
    "can you" "spot the bug",
    "in this list of strings",
    "where a comma is missing?",
)

Your example reproduces only when the strings are too long for the line length:

% black -c '''some_func(
    "can you"
    "spot the bug",
    "in this list of strings",
    "where a comma is missing?",
)
''' -l 20           
some_func(
    "can you"
    "spot the bug",
    "in this list of strings",
    "where a comma is missing?",
)

Now, we previously implemented the behavior you request, but reverted it in #3640 for stability reasons. Might be worth revisiting though.

from black.