dependency resolution issue after lein2 clean about drawbridge HOT 5 CLOSED

Except that drawbridge doesn't require 1.1.0. I suspect you are aiming to use some version of ring >= to that, but drawbridge's lower dependency is (unfortunately) overriding it.

This same problem will occur when using any library that doesn't require a newer version of ring, because ring itself only specifies a "soft" version number dependency on ring-core. If that were changed to e.g. [ring/ring-core "[1.1.0,)"] (meaning, that ring v1.1.0 requires 1.1.0 or higher of ring-core), then drawbridge's lower version dependency would not countermand that.

Maybe this is something @weavejester would consider for future releases?

from drawbridge.

I tend to steer clear of version ranges for these reasons.

from drawbridge.

Like most "X considered harmful" sorts of posts, some subtleties and certain circumstances that are glossed over. Version ranges are sometimes indispensable.

@ccfontes I would suggest changing your ring dependency(ies) to a version that sets 1.1.0 as a hard lower bound, instead of the "soft" version number I presume you have set currently.

from drawbridge.

There may be rare circumstances where version ranges are useful, but in general I find they're more trouble than they're worth. For example, if [ring "1.1.0"] had a dependency of [ring/ring.core "[1.1.0,)"], then it would depend on the latest snapshot of Ring, which might be incompatible with 1.1.0 (e.g. a hypothetical [ring/ring.core "2.0.0-SNAPSHOT"])

In general it's best to stick with soft version numbers, and to remember that the closer dependencies take priority over the latter ones. This can cause problems, but they can be resolved by specifying explicit dependencies in your project file. Problems with version ranges, particularly hard ones, are not so easily to resolve.

from drawbridge.

Using [com.cemerick/drawbridge "$VERSION" :exclusions [ring/ring-core]] will have to be the "official" workaround until something can be done to smooth this general problem over in Leiningen (see cemerick/friend#15 for another example).

from drawbridge.