Comment system to posts about shaark HOT 8 CLOSED

Laravel Shaarli is a self-hosted platform to keep and share your content: web links, posts, passwords and pictures.

I disagree with having a comment system. I would use a blog if I wanted comments.

But if the decision is made to implement a comment system, please keep it disabled by default. :)

from shaark.

Yep, it can be a good idea but need a lot a changes to allow users to register. Maybe a public comment system with grey-listing. Example: you post a comment with username + email + comment. The comment is not displayed and need to be moderated. Once you have been moderated once, your comments are now auto-moderated.

from shaark.

Good point. I forget about registration. What about Disqus integration? For this, no registration for shaarli is needed.

from shaark.

Nope, the philosophy of Laravel Shaarli is to be third-party free. This is why there's no CDN, no tracker, no cool web services (such Google Fonts, etc).

What do you think about my comment integration?

from shaark.

I would also prefer to have my own system. I think moderation is a good thing in itself, but it would also require some effort in the long run. Automatic moderation would be cool, but in the variant suggested by you, it might be a security problem. Everyone can enter a mail+username combination that has already been moderated.

I suppose it would be better to eventually allow a registration where only one moderation is required.
Guests should always. When commenting as a guest, a captcha would also be worth considering.

from shaark.

In my suggestion, email address of the user who's commenting is hidden. So nobody can use the username and the email of an already moderated user. I think it can be a good idea to implements comment system like this and in the future, allowing user to register.

from shaark.

Seconded. I pick stuff that doesn't have comment support deliberately. I don't like the idea of the new iteration of Shaarli having comment support, but if it happens, please make it possible to disable it.

from shaark.

Released in 1.2.33

from shaark.