bug: Translation in Sign-in Experience is incorrect about logto HOT 4 OPEN

Thanks for reporting. This is reproducible and thus confirmed as a bug. We'll let you know when it's fixed.

A workaround: You can modify the general_required and username (lowercase) fields, as currently the username required error message is a conjunction of these two.

from logto.

Just double checked and confirmed this is currently "by design". At sign-in flow, since the "sign-in identifiers" might be more than one (you can enable username, email and phone at the same time at sign-in), so we don't actually know what the field type is. Therefore, general_required i18n key is used instead of the specific key username_required.

The username_required key, however, is only used at registration flow, since the sign-up identifier can only be one.

We'll still try to improve the user experience in the future.

from logto.

Thanks for workaround. However, I've changed username to the custom value but some part of error cannot be changed or be translated. There still be ทดสอบ is required.

And the forgot-password flow is also affected by this bug as the following. The username in sign-in page, and email in forgot-password page are using the same general_required error message.

Changing the value of general_required affect both sign-in and forgot-password page. Is there any workaround? @charIeszhao

from logto.

@pramotetrs, I don't think I get your last question, as it seems it's going work if you change the value of general_required, isn't it? Why do you ask for another workaround?

from logto.