Follow-up Check about ronataswestoldturkic HOT 6 CLOSED

Nice repo, as far as I can tell. I would say this also merits a blog post, if you want, as it is a larger concept list. Specifically, I'd say we should try and do the following:

• add concept list in its entirety to concepticon (ideally in April, so we can include it into concepticon 2.7, which we want to release by the end of April)
• check the forms in EDICTOR using pyedictor
• change license to cc-by-4.0, since this is the license we recommend for lexibank
• add a description of the data and how it was digitized in NOTES.md (will be included in readme.md later)

from ronataswestoldturkic.

The metadata.json should be adjusted a bit (the year is missing in the CLDF dataset derived from X and Y's "PAPER SHORT TITLE" from YEAR)

from ronataswestoldturkic.

Yep, this can definitely be done!

from ronataswestoldturkic.

Implemented all suggestions (changes can be viewed in the commits history), only pending thing is submitting the concept list to concepticon, where I have opened an issue.

I'm sorry about the late reply, hope there's still the chance to write a blog post or similar about this some day

from ronataswestoldturkic.

Update: all suggestions in #3 (comment) have been implemented. Now working on the blog-post, which can be accessed at this non-public repository: https://github.com/calc-project/calc-project/issues/91#issuecomment-1285592122

from ronataswestoldturkic.

@LinguList I went through the repo once more, fixing some issues that came up recently. I think there might still be two open issues:

• #20
• I remember vaguely that there was something wrong with col "Loan" in forms.csv. Might be this is a precedence and we have to brainstorm what the best convention would be. As I've understood the col "Loan" is supposed to tell whether the word in question is a loanword or not. That's why I've manually tagged all historical stages of Hungarian (H, OH, EAH, LAH) as True, and for West Old Turkic I went manually through the source pdf and set the value to True where the West Old Turkic word itself was borrowed (usually from a Mongolic language)

Maybe you could have one final look at the repo and see what could be still improved, so it can be added to lexibank :)

from ronataswestoldturkic.