Avoid adding index file to the resources by default about jandex-gradle-plugin HOT 10 CLOSED

I do. The standard location for the licence file is /META-INF/LICENSE rather than /LICENSE, and shade plugins recognize that. On top of that, the license management plugins recognize that and they can gather and infer dependency licenses.

This validates my point regarding a resource transformer that targets Jandex index files until the time comes (if it comes) when Jandex offers an index merge option.

It would help if the documentation clarified when the index is automatically added to the jar, and when it is not.

The readme shows the default value of the destination property as build/resources/main/META-INF/jandex.idx

from jandex-gradle-plugin.

Funny you mention this, the first releases placed the index file at a different location however changes were made to align this plugin with its Maven counterpart. You can change the location of the generated index file by setting the destination property on the jandex task.

from jandex-gradle-plugin.

I doubt the index would be usable for a library in case the filename is customized, so I'm inclined to avoid including it at all.

from jandex-gradle-plugin.

Hmm I guess I'm missing something here. The plugin does give you options to change either the name of the index, its location, or both. It's up to you as library author to decide which conventions to follow. This being said, if the location is changed to a different path then you'd still need additional configuration in the build file if the index has to be included in a JAR at some point. Thus, if the conventions are followed you don't need extra configuration, but if you do deviate from the conventions then you require additional configuration.

A consumer that decides to shade resources would have to follow their own conventions, deal with potentially colliding entries. It's not the job of the index producer to solve this particular problem.

from jandex-gradle-plugin.

if the location is changed to a different path then you'd still need additional configuration in the build file if the index has t be included in a JAR

I see. I thought it would be included into the jar under a customized name.

It's not the job of the index producer to solve this particular problem

In practice, collision resolution is not very well implemented.
As you might know, a top-level /LICENSE would easily produce a collision. Unfortunately, consumers are not much into fixing that :(

Note: jandex misses the ability to merge indices, so consumers won't have an option to merge indices when they shade dependencies.
One of the solutions is to throw-away all the indicices and reindex after shading, however, that would require extra build configuration, and the benefits from the library author's perspective look very small 🤷‍♂️

That is why I would refrain from adding a fixed-named file to a library (e.g. https://github.com/pgjdbc/pgjdbc/ ).

Note: I do not need the index for my library yet. I have no use case for it. I want to pass the classes through jandex to ensure that the resulting bytecode is parseable by jandex.

Unfortunately, jandex has issues, and it results in Hibernate failing in surprising ways even though pgjdbc's bytecode is perfectly valid.

This PR fixes classes that Jandex can't parse, and the only thing I want for now is a CI check that would ensure jandex compatibility. Of course, I would love jandex bugs to be fixed, however, it would take time for everybody to upgrade.

from jandex-gradle-plugin.

re: License file. Precisely. You don't see plugin/library authors trying to fix this particular file name, do you? Because the "problem" is on the consumer side that requires shading, not on the producing side.

I understand that Jandex has some short comings and the fixes may take some time to appear. Merging jandex index files could be done by Jandex itself or as an external shade/shadow transformer (like the [PropertiesFileTransformer](https://github.com/kordamp/maven-shade-ext-transformers) available to both Maven shade and Gradle shadow). This transformer is unrelated to the index producing plugin (Maven or Gradle).

This plugin lets you configure index name, location, and sources as needed. If the conventions are followed then there's little to no extra configuration needed. If a different convention is needed then extra configuration is mandated. I don't see what else needs to be updated/modified here, unless perhaps we enter a discussion on how much extra configuration may be required from a consumer's POV.

from jandex-gradle-plugin.

You don't see plugin/library authors trying to fix this particular file name, do you?

I do. The standard location for the licence file is /META-INF/LICENSE rather than /LICENSE, and shade plugins recognize that. On top of that, the license management plugins recognize that and they can gather and infer dependency licenses.

For example, junit4 renamed the file to LICENSE-junit.txt :( (however, they should have better be using the standard META-INF/LICENSE location)

I understand that Jandex has some short comings and the fixes may take some time to appear

I've filed the corresponding issue: smallrye/jandex#100

unless perhaps we enter a discussion on how much extra configuration

It would help if the documentation clarified when the index is automatically added to the jar, and when it is not.

from jandex-gradle-plugin.

The readme shows the default value of the destination property as build/resources/main/META-INF/jandex.idx

It does not look like "adds index to the jar" or "does not add index to the jar" to me :-/

Just in case, I just tried 0.8.0, and it looks like a customized destination does not make a difference.
I guess it is caused by

from jandex-gradle-plugin.

Just in case, the sequence of the tasks for ./gradlew jar --dry-run is as follows:

Building pgjdbc 42.2.18-SNAPSHOT
:postgresql:preprocessVersion SKIPPED
:postgresql:compileJava SKIPPED
:postgresql:processResources SKIPPED // <-- destination overwrite happens here
:postgresql:classes SKIPPED
:postgresql:jandex SKIPPED
:postgresql:jar SKIPPED

from jandex-gradle-plugin.

Indeed. The JandexPlugin is responsible for copying the index file to the resources directory, even if a different location was specified. This happens only for the explicit jandex task but not for any other task of type JandexTask. I'll add a config option to the task to keep or skip this step.

from jandex-gradle-plugin.