Use as smarthost with authentication? about smtp HOT 6 CLOSED

The problem is that total packages like mailcow, mailu etc, take a ton of overhead to run, rather than a few kb.

That's what @tlex is saying and that this package isn't appropriate for use cases that'd turn it into that. :-)

I like docker-mailserver for a reasonable trade-off when I need authentication (etc).

from smtp.

Thank you for your question. This project doesn't support authentication, nor does it have it in scope. You can also see my response in #14 for this.

I am willing to accept merge/pull requests for a method to do that, however I think user management will blow up the code base.

from smtp.

This is only for outgoing relay so running a full MTA would be a huge overkill with incoming mail handling, spam etc. All I need is like a simple .htaccess style access control for allowing relaying of mail. I feel I looked everywhere but it just doesn't look like it exist. Everybody suggest just using gmail as the outgoing relay, but as exactly what I want to avoid.

from smtp.

Well, the problem with doing this with exim (which is the MTA inside this package) is that it needs one more daemon running, to handle the authentication of the users. You can take a look on the old ubuntu wiki page to see the challenges related to adding individual users.

I strongly suggest you look into other MTAs. You don't need to open access for inbound traffic. You don't need to add it to your DNS. But you do need the user handling. There are some very nice projects out there to handle users (also https://mailu.io/2.0/ comes to mind).

from smtp.

The problem is that total packages like mailcow, mailu etc, take a ton of overhead to run, rather than a few kb. I'm not particularly after exim, any MTA will do. Do you if any other would be hard to setup in this way? I can't believe I'm the only person in the world who are looking for selfhosting something like this, rather than have commercial providers look over their shoulder.

from smtp.

Adding simple username/password authentication is not going to turn ix-ai/smtp into mailcow, come on, be realistic.

from smtp.