Comments (3)
vaklinov
commented on September 27, 2024
There are several parts to this issue:
One is an enhancement request: "something that said how much the total transaction was going to be before sending it on both transparent and shielded transactions." It is indeed a good idea. The BitcoinQT core wallet for instance shows the details of the transaction in a dialog box and asks the user if he is sure he wants to send the transaction. The same could be done for the ZEN wallet..
Another part has to do with errors reported when low transaction fees are used. Such errors come from the ZEN node itself. Examples:
Sending a transaction with a non-zero fee and zero amount is not possible:
zen-cli z_sendmany zc8MXGgzRTvkw3RbBGihv59StE1BhmLKK54pTXSgRWcokC93owi1nvpxdwFpqXy2jZ1p1Nz9dZKnBd13KeuTNLLks5DCAAP [{"address":"zceSqZ5Sd99LTy5RMYCHSdjDPJS5EqVBB2Ld73ba3aCuS9Muky2zGxnT9eeH67wbzNdEZTRBMLXKCGxHdXRAc12be5Mcm8p","memo":"54455354","amount":0.00}] 1 0.00001
...
[AWT-EventQueue-0] [Tue Aug 01 23:25:44 EEST 2017] [ERROR] Unexpected error:
com.vaklinov.zcashui.ZCashClientCaller$WalletCallException: Error response from wallet: error code: -8
error message:
Fee 0.00001 is greater than the sum of outputs 0.00
The error is reported by the ZEN node - the GUI wallet cannot do anything about it.
Attempting to zend a Z->Z transaction with zero fee and zero amount also produces an error:
zen-cli z_sendmany zc8MXGgzRTvkw3RbBGihv59StE1BhmLKK54pTXSgRWcokC93owi1nvpxdwFpqXy2jZ1p1Nz9dZKnBd13KeuTNLLks5DCAAP [{"address":"zcMeDN38eS3ydUXQsmqQ1UJ9nvpksXrGL92x31SJd4ekj4JWuobr8pi9eR9dtxfhYggXSGpopVefVZDmjxCbzWdwKd7QoHo","memo":"544553543434","amount":0.00}] 1 0.00.
[AWT-EventQueue-0] [Tue Aug 01 23:29:42 EEST 2017] [INFO] Sending cash with the following command: /home/ivan/workspaces/ZENCashGit1/zen/src/zen-cli z_sendmany zc8MXGgzRTvkw3RbBGihv59StE1BhmLKK54pTXSgRWcokC93owi1nvpxdwFpqXy2jZ1p1Nz9dZKnBd13KeuTNLLks5DCAAP [{"address":"zcMeDN38eS3ydUXQsmqQ1UJ9nvpksXrGL92x31SJd4ekj4JWuobr8pi9eR9dtxfhYggXSGpopVefVZDmjxCbzWdwKd7QoHo","memo":"544553543434","amount":0.00}] 1 0.00. Got result: [opid-42018389-18d5-4016-acd8-64d6a0a2b4be
]
[Thread-52779] [Tue Aug 01 23:29:42 EEST 2017] [INFO] Operation opid-42018389-18d5-4016-acd8-64d6a0a2b4be status is [{"id":"opid-42018389-18d5-4016-acd8-64d6a0a2b4be","status":"failed","creation_time":1501619382,"error":{"code":-4,"message":"Missing hex data for raw transaction"},"method":"z_sendmany","params":{"fromaddress":"zc8MXGgzRTvkw3RbBGihv59StE1BhmLKK54pTXSgRWcokC93owi1nvpxdwFpqXy2jZ1p1Nz9dZKnBd13KeuTNLLks5DCAAP","amounts":[{"address":"zcMeDN38eS3ydUXQsmqQ1UJ9nvpksXrGL92x31SJd4ekj4JWuobr8pi9eR9dtxfhYggXSGpopVefVZDmjxCbzWdwKd7QoHo","memo":"544553543434","amount":0.00}],"minconf":1,"fee":0}}].
Again the error is reported by the ZEN node - the GUI wallet cannot do anything about it.
Interestingly a T->Z transaction with zero fee and zero amount succeeds ;-) in the long run however miners will probably reject transactions with zero/low fees...
from zencash-swing-wallet-ui.
vaklinov
commented on September 27, 2024
Successful T->Z transaction with zero fee and zero amount:
Log excerpt:
[AWT-EventQueue-0] [Tue Aug 01 23:38:50 EEST 2017] [INFO] The following send command will be issued: /home/ivan/workspaces/ZENCashGit1/zen/src/zen-cli z_sendmany znW67KeSTfWGtBAJTCU9q4b3qSx1xudxbtc [{"address":"zcMeDN38eS3ydUXQsmqQ1UJ9nvpksXrGL92x31SJd4ekj4JWuobr8pi9eR9dtxfhYggXSGpopVefVZDmjxCbzWdwKd7QoHo","memo":"544553543535","amount":0.00}] 1 0.00.
[AWT-EventQueue-0] [Tue Aug 01 23:38:50 EEST 2017] [INFO] Sending cash with the following command: /home/ivan/workspaces/ZENCashGit1/zen/src/zen-cli z_sendmany znW67KeSTfWGtBAJTCU9q4b3qSx1xudxbtc [{"address":"zcMeDN38eS3ydUXQsmqQ1UJ9nvpksXrGL92x31SJd4ekj4JWuobr8pi9eR9dtxfhYggXSGpopVefVZDmjxCbzWdwKd7QoHo","memo":"544553543535","amount":0.00}] 1 0.00. Got result: [opid-f80d4ece-5513-4f3e-9ec1-a8c11100a129]
...
[AWT-EventQueue-0] [Tue Aug 01 23:41:10 EEST 2017] [INFO] Operation opid-f80d4ece-5513-4f3e-9ec1-a8c11100a129 status is [{"id":"opid-f80d4ece-5513-4f3e-9ec1-a8c11100a129","status":"success","creation_time":1501619930,"result":{"txid":"5ff021c89cbec55fdebec75d933c4c6f39bc8f4d48fb3ba51f5d4717cfa827ba"},"execution_secs":137.638562411,"method":"z_sendmany","params":{"fromaddress":"znW67KeSTfWGtBAJTCU9q4b3qSx1xudxbtc","amounts":[{"address":"zcMeDN38eS3ydUXQsmqQ1UJ9nvpksXrGL92x31SJd4ekj4JWuobr8pi9eR9dtxfhYggXSGpopVefVZDmjxCbzWdwKd7QoHo","memo":"544553543535","amount":0.00}],"minconf":1,"fee":0}}].
from zencash-swing-wallet-ui.
Sto1cNate
commented on September 27, 2024
@zennermac should be able to close this one.
from zencash-swing-wallet-ui.
Related Issues (20)
- When attempting to move ZenCashWallet to Applications folder on Mac: "The operation can’t be completed because you don’t have permission to access some of the items." HOT 9
- deposits not showing HOT 8
- Wallet.dat is corrupted but readable with STRINGS/HexDump HOT 2
- sapling? update HOT 2
- ZenCash Swing Wallet Issue HOT 3
- How horizen swing-wallet migrates block directory files HOT 7
- Error dialog displayed after sitting idle for hours does not close HOT 1
- Application name in Windows task manager shows description instead of app name HOT 1
- Internet Is Fine & I've Had The Swing Wallet Open & Still 0 Connections HOT 2
- Typo on releases page HOT 1
- Price Values missing HOT 2
- Wallets not accepting private key format HOT 1
- qa/rpc-tests/sc_02.py
- Error sending cash: Witness for note commitment is null HOT 4
- Witness for note commitment is null HOT 2
- Deb package still shows old ZenCash icon
- Troubleshooting page gives 404 error
- How can I get into the ZENCashWallet? HOT 1
- Price feed not working HOT 2
- ZEN Cash Wallet error to send funds HOT 3
Recommend Projects
-
React
A declarative, efficient, and flexible JavaScript library for building user interfaces.
-
Vue.js
🖖 Vue.js is a progressive, incrementally-adoptable JavaScript framework for building UI on the web.
-
Typescript
TypeScript is a superset of JavaScript that compiles to clean JavaScript output.
-
TensorFlow
An Open Source Machine Learning Framework for Everyone
-
Django
The Web framework for perfectionists with deadlines.
-
Laravel
A PHP framework for web artisans
-
D3
Bring data to life with SVG, Canvas and HTML. 📊📈🎉
-
Recommend Topics
-
javascript
JavaScript (JS) is a lightweight interpreted programming language with first-class functions.
-
web
Some thing interesting about web. New door for the world.
-
server
A server is a program made to process requests and deliver data to clients.
-
Machine learning
Machine learning is a way of modeling and interpreting data that allows a piece of software to respond intelligently.
-
Visualization
Some thing interesting about visualization, use data art
-
Game
Some thing interesting about game, make everyone happy.
Recommend Org
-
Facebook
We are working to build community through open source technology. NB: members must have two-factor auth.
-
Microsoft
Open source projects and samples from Microsoft.
-
Google
Google ❤️ Open Source for everyone.
-
Alibaba
Alibaba Open Source for everyone
-
D3
Data-Driven Documents codes.
-
Tencent
China tencent open source team.
from zencash-swing-wallet-ui.