Public role allow to create empty user. about directus HOT 7 CLOSED

That was indeed a bit quick to assume that it would work with the changes from my end, sorry about that.
After looking at it a bit more it looks like is the identical problem as in #21873 (comment) which is tracked in #22278. As such I'm still gonna leave this issue closed :)

As for your problem, I just verified that the exact workaround suggested in #21873 (comment) works here as well.
Set the field preset for "email" to null

from directus.

@hanneskuettner Great. That works. Thank you so much.

from directus.

@rem2akhmad Did you pass the role to new user?
in access control under system collections, directus_users use custom for Create and check email, password and role

from directus.

@rem2akhmad Did you pass the role to new user? in access control under system collections, directus_users use custom for Create and check email, password and role

There is no user before the call. It's "Public" role which is system role with "null" PK. Check email and password filters doesn't work either.

from directus.

You need to move the "email isn't null" and "email isn't" empty checks into the AND group, like so:

from directus.

You need to move the "email isn't null" and "email isn't" empty checks into the AND group, like so:

same result

PS small correction, but result still the same. This rule doesn't work.

from directus.

Seems like you are trying to check email if it exist in request, but there is no way to make this field required. At least I don't know how to do that.

https://github.com/directus/directus/blob/main/api/src/services/users.ts#L176

And one more question. Why this issue marked as "Done" when it easy to repro and observe results?
@hanneskuettner @mahsamirzapour

from directus.