Comments (30)
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
What Android version?
What do you mean by "switching the delay"
What is your input sample rate?
Can you check the adb log?
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
What Android version?
This happend on 2 devices with Android 9 and 1 device with FireOS7 (Android 9 as well)
What do you mean by "switching the delay"
In the app, adjust the delay in ms for the device to achieve syncronized playback.
What is your input sample rate?
Im using a spotify pipe from librespot.
pipe:///share/snapfifo/librespot?name=SpotifyConnect&sampleformat=44100:16:2
Can you check the adb log?
Just a general adb logcat? I will see what I can do later about that :)
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
EDIT - Seems to be a problem with Battery Optimization. After turning it off for snapcast this seems ok again.
EDIT2 - Same Problem on FireTV Devices. App stops playing at some point.
I just discovered another problem with the new client.
They now stop on their own. I was able to capture the logcat output of it:
03-06 16:21:11.001 12861 9558 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -4 -4 1 0 500 7 -3
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: java.io.InterruptedIOException: read interrupted
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at libcore.io.Linux.readBytes(Native Method)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at libcore.io.Linux.read(Linux.java:184)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at libcore.io.BlockGuardOs.read(BlockGuardOs.java:254)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at libcore.io.IoBridge.read(IoBridge.java:501)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.FileInputStream.read(FileInputStream.java:307)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.BufferedInputStream.read1(BufferedInputStream.java:286)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.BufferedInputStream.read(BufferedInputStream.java:347)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at sun.nio.cs.StreamDecoder.readBytes(StreamDecoder.java:288)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at sun.nio.cs.StreamDecoder.implRead(StreamDecoder.java:351)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at sun.nio.cs.StreamDecoder.read(StreamDecoder.java:180)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.InputStreamReader.read(InputStreamReader.java:184)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.BufferedReader.fill(BufferedReader.java:172)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.BufferedReader.readLine(BufferedReader.java:335)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.BufferedReader.readLine(BufferedReader.java:400)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at de.badaix.snapcast.SnapclientService$1.run(SnapclientService.java:267)
03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.lang.Thread.run(Thread.java:764)
03-06 16:21:11.688 12861 12861 D Main : onPlayerStop
03-06 16:21:11.688 12861 12861 D Main : updateStartStopMenuItem: ic_media_play
And here is the logcat output when the error tone happens when muting a device:
03-06 16:57:00.001 12861 14446 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 2 2 -5 -1 500 7 -1
--
03-06 16:57:01.001 12861 14446 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 7 4 |
03-06 16:57:02.001 12861 14446 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 -1 -1 0 500 7 0
03-06 16:57:03.001 12861 14446 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -1 -1 0 0 500 7 0
03-06 16:57:03.684 12861 14446 D Main : [Info] (onMessageReceived) ServerSettings - buffer: 700, latency: 0, volume: 86, muted: 1
03-06 16:57:03.687 12861 11349 D TCP : Received Message: '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"Client.OnVolumeChanged","params":{"id":"73031233-5f2d-4e91-9179-1987bcfd1fe9","volume":{"muted":true,"percent":86}}}'
03-06 16:57:04.001 12861 14446 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 0 500 7 0 |
03-06 16:57:04.253 12861 14446 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception | |
FIRETV LOG:
Device keeps playing fine if latency is set to 0. As soon as i increase it to 200 audio is full of errors
03-06 17:18:33.434 7167 8056 D TCP : Received Message: '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"Client.OnVolumeChanged","params":{"id":"7d90ab52-887e-4145-92bb-c8384d7422b5","volume":{"muted":false,"percent":28}}}'
03-06 17:18:33.649 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 1 325 0
03-06 17:18:34.016 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 64 310 0
03-06 17:18:35.002 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 227 330 0
03-06 17:18:36.000 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 377 310 0
03-06 17:18:37.024 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 1 0 500 310 0
03-06 17:18:38.002 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 323 -2
03-06 17:18:39.008 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 310 0
03-06 17:18:40.032 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 310 0
03-06 17:18:40.255 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (onMessageReceived) ServerSettings - buffer: 700, latency: 0, volume: 75, muted: 0
03-06 17:18:40.255 7167 8056 D TCP : Received Message: '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"Client.OnVolumeChanged","params":{"id":"7d90ab52-887e-4145-92bb-c8384d7422b5","volume":{"muted":false,"percent":75}}}'
03-06 17:18:41.002 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 0 500 315 0
03-06 17:18:42.018 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 0 0 1 500 308 -2
03-06 17:18:43.002 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 1 500 332 0
03-06 17:18:44.000 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 1 500 310 -2
03-06 17:18:45.025 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 1 500 310 -2
03-06 17:18:46.002 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 0 0 500 324 0
03-06 17:18:47.009 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 0 0 500 309 0
03-06 17:18:48.002 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 1 500 337 0
03-06 17:18:49.002 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 1 500 316 -2
03-06 17:18:49.291 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (onMessageReceived) ServerSettings - buffer: 700, latency: 200, volume: 75, muted: 0
03-06 17:18:49.293 7167 8056 D TCP : Received Message: '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"Client.OnLatencyChanged","params":{"id":"7d90ab52-887e-4145-92bb-c8384d7422b5","latency":200}}'
03-06 17:18:49.376 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pMiniBuffer->full() && (abs(pMiniBuffer->mean()) > 50): 200049
03-06 17:18:49.396 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:49.466 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:49.521 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:49.577 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:49.649 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:49.778 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:49.841 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:49.906 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.016 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 9 310 -1
03-06 17:18:50.039 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.097 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.167 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.282 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.353 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.417 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.481 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.617 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.673 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.745 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.802 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.861 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:50.929 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.003 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.058 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 1 324 0
03-06 17:18:51.058 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.121 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.185 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.258 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.321 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.376 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.450 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.519 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.578 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.633 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.698 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.761 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.836 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.899 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:51.953 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.017 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 1 325 0
03-06 17:18:52.028 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.081 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.153 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.209 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.281 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.338 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.401 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.473 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.537 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.602 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.730 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.801 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.857 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.915 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:52.977 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:53.041 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 1 325 0
03-06 17:18:53.113 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:53.177 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:53.235 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:53.305 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:53.377 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:53.433 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:53.492 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:53.561 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:53.689 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:53.754 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:53.817 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:53.881 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:54.002 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 5 323 0
03-06 17:18:54.009 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:54.137 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:54.262 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:54.393 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:54.520 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:54.586 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:54.697 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:54.778 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:54.842 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:54.969 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:55.017 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 1 322 0
03-06 17:18:55.033 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:55.161 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:55.290 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:55.401 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:55.531 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:55.659 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:55.720 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:55.787 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:55.867 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:55.980 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:56.044 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 1 322 0
03-06 17:18:56.058 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:56.124 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:56.236 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:56.316 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:56.497 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:56.574 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:56.702 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:56.753 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:56.814 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:56.881 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:56.942 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.002 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.056 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 1 310 0
03-06 17:18:57.073 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.151 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.201 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.263 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.329 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.457 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.521 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.586 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.713 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.777 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.841 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:57.977 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:58.024 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 1 328 0
03-06 17:18:58.033 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:58.095 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
03-06 17:18:58.128 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (onMessageReceived) ServerSettings - buffer: 700, latency: 200, volume: 75, muted: 1
03-06 17:18:58.129 7167 8056 D TCP : Received Message: '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"Client.OnVolumeChanged","params":{"id":"7d90ab52-887e-4145-92bb-c8384d7422b5","volume":{"muted":true,"percent":75}}}'
03-06 17:18:58.153 7167 7212 D Main : [Info] (getPlayerChunk) Exception
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
ok, thanks.
raising the latency will lower the overall available buffer. Your tablet's audio buffer is quite large (~320ms) adding a latency of 200, will result in 520. Then you have a some latency on top for the stream capture, the codec, the network and the resampler (all Android devices I've seen so far have a low latency/native sample rate of 48kHz, snapclient will resample the signal with soxr, because I've seen on a Samsung galaxy that the "non-native" samplerate will produce quite unstable latency reporting, resulting in unstable "Chunk" numbers (Chunk: 0 0 0 0 1 328 0) and thus high jitter.
You should observe the same problems with the 0.17 on your tablet.
What about the other issues? Were they solved when turning of the battery optimization?
Also this shouldn't have changed from the 0.17.
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
Ok, if i understand you correct, i need to increase the buffer on the server side?
All this just changed after the update to 0.19. Before none of that had happend so far.
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
so is it working without battery optimization? I was just listening for half an hour with battery optimization turned on, not charging and display off.
The latency issue you will have with all versions. Did you update the server also?
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
No i did not update the server yet. Only thing i changed is the client.
In the meantime, one of my clients is offline even though battery optimization is turned off.
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
When does this stop happen?
I just discovered another problem with the new client.
They now stop on their own. I was able to capture the logcat output of it:03-06 16:21:11.001 12861 9558 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -4 -4 1 0 500 7 -3 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: java.io.InterruptedIOException: read interrupted 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at libcore.io.Linux.readBytes(Native Method) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at libcore.io.Linux.read(Linux.java:184) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at libcore.io.BlockGuardOs.read(BlockGuardOs.java:254) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at libcore.io.IoBridge.read(IoBridge.java:501) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.FileInputStream.read(FileInputStream.java:307) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.BufferedInputStream.read1(BufferedInputStream.java:286) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.BufferedInputStream.read(BufferedInputStream.java:347) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at sun.nio.cs.StreamDecoder.readBytes(StreamDecoder.java:288) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at sun.nio.cs.StreamDecoder.implRead(StreamDecoder.java:351) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at sun.nio.cs.StreamDecoder.read(StreamDecoder.java:180) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.InputStreamReader.read(InputStreamReader.java:184) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.BufferedReader.fill(BufferedReader.java:172) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.BufferedReader.readLine(BufferedReader.java:335) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.io.BufferedReader.readLine(BufferedReader.java:400) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at de.badaix.snapcast.SnapclientService$1.run(SnapclientService.java:267) 03-06 16:21:11.684 12861 9558 W System.err: at java.lang.Thread.run(Thread.java:764) 03-06 16:21:11.688 12861 12861 D Main : onPlayerStop 03-06 16:21:11.688 12861 12861 D Main : updateStartStopMenuItem: ic_media_play
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
Offline means the client is disconnected or the WiFi is turned off?
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
Offline means the client is disconnected or the WiFi is turned off?
The Wifi is still on, but the snapcast app is disconnected. (The play button on the top right shows)
If I press it, it starts playing again.
I cannot pinpoint when this happens. The device is playing fine for some minutes, and at some point just disconnects.
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
Sounds almost like the wakelock is not properly acquired. What version were you using before? The 0.17.1.3?
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
Sounds almost like the wakelock is not properly acquired. What version were you using before? The 0.17.1.3?
The one that was previously on Playstore. I dont remember the version number.
Yesterday night I was playing on the firetv via snapcast. This morning, there is again no playback via the app. Connecting to logcat shows that the app receives volume changes and mute but doesn't playback anything.
03-07 08:05:12.062 7167 26334 D Main : [Info] (onMessageReceived) ServerSettings - buffer: 1000, latency: 200, volume: 50, muted: 0
03-07 08:05:12.062 7167 26210 D TCP : Received Message: '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"Client.OnVolumeChanged","params":{"id":"7d90ab52-887e-4145-92bb-c8384d7422b5","volume":{"muted":false,"percent":50}}}'
03-07 08:06:01.779 7167 26334 D Main : [Info] (onMessageReceived) ServerSettings - buffer: 1000, latency: 200, volume: 50, muted: 1
03-07 08:06:01.780 7167 26210 D TCP : Received Message: '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"Client.OnVolumeChanged","params":{"id":"7d90ab52-887e-4145-92bb-c8384d7422b5","volume":{"muted":true,"percent":50}}}'
03-07 08:06:03.498 7167 26334 D Main : [Info] (onMessageReceived) ServerSettings - buffer: 1000, latency: 200, volume: 50, muted: 0
03-07 08:06:03.498 7167 26210 D TCP : Received Message: '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"Client.OnVolumeChanged","params":{"id":"7d90ab52-887e-4145-92bb-c8384d7422b5","volume":{"muted":false,"percent":50}}}'
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
ok, damn, the last PlayStore version is not in releases on this GitHub page. It must have been the 0.17.0.
Can you please try the 0.17.1.1 from the releases page?
This version is almost the same, except that the binary has been renamed from "snapclient" to "snapclient.so" because of some Android restrictions regarding native binaries.
Also I built a new version where the audio engine can be selected. If you change the engine from "Auto" to "OpenSL" and uncheck "Resample audio stream", then this version should behave like the 0.17.1.1.
Unfortunately, not all file extensions are allowed in the issue tracker, so you have to unzip and push the apk on you device with adb:
Snapcast_0.19.0.1.apk.zip
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
Yesterday night I was playing on the firetv via snapcast. This morning, there is again no playback via the app. Connecting to logcat shows that the app receives volume changes and mute but doesn't playback anything.
03-07 08:05:12.062 7167 26334 D Main : [Info] (onMessageReceived) ServerSettings - buffer: 1000, latency: 200, volume: 50, muted: 0 03-07 08:05:12.062 7167 26210 D TCP : Received Message: '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"Client.OnVolumeChanged","params":{"id":"7d90ab52-887e-4145-92bb-c8384d7422b5","volume":{"muted":false,"percent":50}}}' 03-07 08:06:01.779 7167 26334 D Main : [Info] (onMessageReceived) ServerSettings - buffer: 1000, latency: 200, volume: 50, muted: 1 03-07 08:06:01.780 7167 26210 D TCP : Received Message: '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"Client.OnVolumeChanged","params":{"id":"7d90ab52-887e-4145-92bb-c8384d7422b5","volume":{"muted":true,"percent":50}}}' 03-07 08:06:03.498 7167 26334 D Main : [Info] (onMessageReceived) ServerSettings - buffer: 1000, latency: 200, volume: 50, muted: 0 03-07 08:06:03.498 7167 26210 D TCP : Received Message: '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"Client.OnVolumeChanged","params":{"id":"7d90ab52-887e-4145-92bb-c8384d7422b5","volume":{"muted":false,"percent":50}}}'
This control stuff is handled natively in Android Java code, while the playback is done by starting an Android service that spawns a cross compiled Snapclient binary. This service seems to be closed by Android in your case, which is strange, since almost only the binary has changed, not the wrapping service.
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
Thank you for releasing a new test version. I just installed the new client on all devices. Selected OpenSL and NoResample.
So far this seems to have fixed the automatic stop on my FireTV device. Also the other devices on Android 9 appear to be fine.
However, i just discovered a new issue that only happens on an older Android Version:
Snapcast installed on Android Tablet (Android 5.1.1)
1. Snapcast client playing
2. Disconnect WiFi on client
3. Reconnect Wifi on Client
4. Snapcast will reconnect, but not continue playing.
5. Turning off and on again the client will resume playback BUT
6. Volume control does not work anymore. Only muting result is as expected. Volume changes either on the client app itself or via other client apps are not working.
7. This only works again after restart of the whole device. Force stop of the app and restarting the app does not help.
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
Can you please try to find out if resampling was causing the issue or the Oboe player (which will be the default for more recent Android versions, starting with Oreo in the "Auto" setting)?
So test once with "Audio engine" set to "Auto" and resampling turned off, and test once with "OpenSL" and resampling turned on. Maybe resampling uses too much CPU time and is killed by Android. In this case I would set the default engine to "Auto" and turn resampling off by default.
Regarding your Lollipop device: this sounds like some strange Android bug on your phone. On some devices it happened that the Android could not reopen the audio player after connection loss (Issue #14), which is actually solved now by restarting the Snapclient binary.
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
It is the Oboe player.
The issue on the old android device not reconnecting is fixed by choosing OBOE & Resampling.
Now I'm checking if in this config the previous issue will return.
FYI: The resampling also makes the audio output much lower in volume.
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
ok, thanks.
I've build another version without LatencyTuner, which might do too much magic. Would be great when you could test this version also (and check if Oboe is working better):
Snapcast_0.19.0.1_wo_latency_tuner.apk.zip
The lowered volume is yet another issue I cannot reproduce :(
When changing the bit depth, this could happen (e.g. 24bit in 32 bit interpreted as 32 bit), but the bit depth will be converted to 16 bit in any case (resampling checked or not).
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
when you could test this version also (and check if Oboe is working better):
I just did. These are the results:
- Oboe without resampling: When muting, the error sound is playing for a short time and quickly fading out.
- Oboe with resampling: Error sounds just playing the whole time when muting. Same as before.
The lowered volume is yet another issue I cannot reproduce :(
Ok, maybe i was exaggerating a bit. The sound is not MUCH lower in volume. But I can clearly hear the difference. Maybe i only found out, because I was plagued by too low volume in the first place.
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
Thanks for pointing me to the muting issue again, somehow I managed to miss this out. This one I can actually reproduce, i.e. will be able to fix it.
What I actually wanted to know is if the latest version (w/o latency tuner) still stops playing after a while?
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
Ok i just tried it on the firetv. Yes the oboe still stops playing. Not sure if its maybe related to some hdmi cec issue though. If i turn off the TV and only the Soundbar is still on, the sound is stopping. The snapcast app still shows as playing ( play button on the top right) but no more sound. With OpenSL this is not a problem
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
Thanks for checking this.
I did a test with my FireTV Box (some later generation), running Fire OS 6.2.7.1, which is based on Android 7.1.2. When using "Auto", Snapdroid will use the OpenSL engine, because Oboe would also use OpenSL, since AAudio is supported starting with Android 8 (Oboe is just a wrapper that uses AAudio if available, and falls back to OpenSL, if not), so you can basically choose between the old OpenSL implementation (Auto and OpenSL) and OpenSL (Oboe).
However, the sync statistics are looking not good on the FireTv:
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 126 23 20 16 217 50 -13
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -77 20 20 16 237 50 -13
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 35 16 20 16 257 50 -9
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -182 6 11 12 277 50 -4
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -46 -3 6 11 297 50 -8
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 38 21 -2 11 317 50 -1
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -127 5 0 11 337 50 1
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 19 -12 -3 10 357 50 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 104 -5 -5 7 377 50 2
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -24 0 -5 5 397 50 4
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 44 33 -2 6 417 50 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -175 2 -5 5 437 50 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -38 33 0 5 457 50 2
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 95 19 2 5 477 50 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -91 7 7 5 497 50 -1
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 2 2 2 2 500 50 -5
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 119 44 7 6 500 50 -2
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -96 2 2 2 500 50 -9
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 31 -7 2 2 500 50 -1
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -110 -21 2 0 500 50 -1
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -45 -24 -7 -1 500 50 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 127 41 -7 -1 500 50 2
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -127 8 0 0 500 50 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 39 3 3 0 500 50 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 109 6 3 0 500 50 -3
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -94 -28 0 -2 500 50 0
This actually looks like my Galaxy S5 without resampling. With resampling the Galaxy gives quite smooth stats.
In best case it should look like:
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 50 0
This is the big advantage of AAudio: when it requests an audio chunk, it gives a very precise estimation when this chunk will be audible, resulting in very smooth statistics. OpenSL doesn't give this estimation at all, it's hard coded to "50ms"
For comparison, my cheap Xiaomi mi A2 lite looks almost perfect:
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 19 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 19 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 -1 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 1
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 19 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 19 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 19 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -2 0 -1 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 1
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
D/Main: [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 20 0
Note that the delay is around 20ms, when resampling is turned off and it plays a 44.1kHz stream (the devices low latency bit rate is 48kHz), the delay is 80ms, i.e. it needs some 60ms more to process the stream. I think that this will be true also for OpenSL (where is delay is not available), so resampling in software should result in some constant device delay, independent of the samplerate.
Also, I could fix the noise when muting the device and some smaller bug related to this.
But I could not reproduce the stopping audio playback, because my ARV is a bit older (w/o HDMI), the FireTV is connected via HDMI to the TV and the TV's audio is connected via TOSLink to the AVR.
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
Ok, so i just checked the logs on the new FireTV (Android 9 based) and with OpenSL the Sync Statistic looks very similar to yours:
03-10 17:20:18.022 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 342 2 2 2 12 50 0
03-10 17:20:19.026 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 380 331 297 297 32 50 0
03-10 17:20:20.024 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 360 360 331 331 52 50 0
03-10 17:20:21.024 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 360 360 331 331 72 50 0
03-10 17:20:22.024 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 361 360 341 341 92 50 0
03-10 17:20:22.464 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pShortBuffer->full() && (abs(shortMedian_) > 5): 34146
03-10 17:20:23.024 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 10 50 0
03-10 17:20:24.007 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -175 0 0 0 30 50 0
03-10 17:20:25.011 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -136 -71 -9 -9 50 50 0
03-10 17:20:26.028 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 39 -70 -23 -23 70 50 0
03-10 17:20:27.005 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -188 -41 -30 -30 90 50 0
03-10 17:20:28.014 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -99 -69 -49 -39 110 50 15
03-10 17:20:29.026 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 24 -29 -69 -39 130 50 16
03-10 17:20:29.061 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pShortBuffer->full() && (abs(shortMedian_) > 5): -6945
03-10 17:20:30.018 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 74 74 74 74 18 50 0
03-10 17:20:31.020 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 96 70 71 71 38 50 0
03-10 17:20:32.002 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -90 62 70 70 58 50 0
03-10 17:20:33.010 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -4 70 70 70 78 50 0
03-10 17:20:34.029 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 180 74 70 70 98 50 0
03-10 17:20:34.162 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pShortBuffer->full() && (abs(shortMedian_) > 5): 7071
03-10 17:20:35.009 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -124 -9 -9 -9 16 50 0
03-10 17:20:36.014 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -70 -27 -27 -27 36 50 0
03-10 17:20:37.026 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 42 -28 -28 -28 56 50 0
03-10 17:20:38.013 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -82 -61 -36 -36 76 50 0
03-10 17:20:39.019 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -29 -36 -36 -36 96 50 0
03-10 17:20:40.003 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -181 -36 -36 -36 116 50 10
03-10 17:20:41.010 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -108 -34 -36 -36 136 50 14
03-10 17:20:42.029 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 79 -31 -44 -36 156 50 15
03-10 17:20:43.007 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -134 -36 -36 -36 176 50 9
03-10 17:20:44.015 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -57 -57 -40 -40 196 50 13
03-10 17:20:45.034 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 137 -17 -36 -36 216 50 14
03-10 17:20:46.014 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -63 -14 -33 -36 236 50 13
03-10 17:20:47.019 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -5 -11 -33 -36 256 50 14
03-10 17:20:48.005 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -143 -8 -25 -36 276 50 12
03-10 17:20:49.011 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -88 -15 -17 -36 296 50 11
03-10 17:20:50.030 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 102 -28 -23 -34 316 50 12
03-10 17:20:51.008 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -108 -27 -27 -34 336 50 12
03-10 17:20:52.016 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -28 -28 -28 -34 356 50 14
03-10 17:20:53.027 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 78 7 -28 -33 376 50 8
03-10 17:20:54.015 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -35 -19 -28 -33 396 50 8
03-10 17:20:55.020 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 13 -11 -20 -30 416 50 9
03-10 17:20:56.007 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -114 11 -18 -29 436 50 1
03-10 17:20:57.013 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -58 -4 -11 -29 456 50 9
03-10 17:20:58.030 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 117 -7 -12 -28 476 50 11
03-10 17:20:59.009 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -89 -15 -12 -28 496 50 4
03-10 17:20:59.261 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pBuffer->full() && (abs(median_) > 2): -2849
03-10 17:21:00.017 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 24 27 27 27 14 50 1
03-10 17:21:01.027 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 122 53 46 46 34 50 0
03-10 17:21:02.015 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 23 27 27 54 50 0
03-10 17:21:03.020 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 52 28 27 27 74 50 0
03-10 17:21:04.004 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -111 27 27 27 94 50 0
03-10 17:21:05.012 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -35 44 27 27 114 50 -10
03-10 17:21:06.030 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 150 30 23 27 134 50 -13
03-10 17:21:07.010 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -56 2 19 23 154 50 -13
03-10 17:21:08.017 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 6 6 12 21 174 50 -10
03-10 17:21:09.027 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 108 44 12 21 194 50 -11
03-10 17:21:10.015 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -13 10 10 19 214 50 -13
03-10 17:21:11.021 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 37 21 7 19 234 50 -8
03-10 17:21:12.005 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -120 8 8 18 254 50 -7
03-10 17:21:13.017 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -1 16 10 18 274 50 -6
03-10 17:21:14.018 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 5 16 10 16 294 50 -12
03-10 17:21:15.006 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -119 -7 7 13 314 50 -8
03-10 17:21:16.018 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 2 2 5 10 334 50 -2
03-10 17:21:17.028 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 99 33 5 10 354 50 -5
03-10 17:21:18.002 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -153 2 2 10 374 50 -5
03-10 17:21:19.021 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 35 6 2 9 394 50 -1
03-10 17:21:20.006 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -115 -2 2 8 414 50 -1
03-10 17:21:21.013 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -52 -26 0 7 434 50 0
03-10 17:21:22.018 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 2 2 0 7 454 50 0
03-10 17:21:23.006 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -118 -2 -2 7 474 50 0
03-10 17:21:24.021 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 30 20 -2 7 494 50 1
03-10 17:21:25.028 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 104 15 -2 7 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:26.003 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -148 9 2 6 500 50 1
03-10 17:21:27.022 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 37 13 3 6 500 50 -1
03-10 17:21:28.008 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -100 2 3 6 500 50 -3
03-10 17:21:29.013 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -47 -19 2 3 500 50 -2
03-10 17:21:30.019 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 7 7 2 2 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:31.007 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -111 6 2 2 500 50 -3
03-10 17:21:32.020 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 16 0 0 2 500 50 -1
03-10 17:21:33.029 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 106 29 0 2 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:34.004 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -137 -2 0 2 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:35.022 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 44 8 0 2 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:36.009 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -88 4 0 0 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:37.014 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -42 -16 -2 0 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:38.019 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 9 9 -14 0 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:39.007 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -106 14 -10 -2 500 50 6
03-10 17:21:40.021 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 29 2 1 0 500 50 2
03-10 17:21:41.029 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 112 -7 -7 0 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:42.004 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -137 -12 -7 -2 500 50 9
03-10 17:21:43.026 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 71 19 -2 -2 500 50 5
03-10 17:21:44.011 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -67 16 -2 -2 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:45.014 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -32 -7 -3 -2 500 50 1
03-10 17:21:46.019 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 20 1 -3 -2 500 50 2
03-10 17:21:47.007 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -100 27 -2 -2 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:48.021 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 41 9 -2 -2 500 50 1
03-10 17:21:49.034 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 168 5 -2 -2 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:50.004 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -129 -19 -6 -3 500 50 1
03-10 17:21:51.023 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 55 9 -2 -2 500 50 6
03-10 17:21:52.006 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -109 11 -10 -3 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:53.015 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -21 2 -5 -3 500 50 7
03-10 17:21:54.020 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 29 7 -1 -2 500 50 0
03-10 17:21:55.008 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -91 8 2 -2 500 50 0
With resampling enabled it looks worse? (at least further away from 0)
03-10 17:25:13.028 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 6 -7 -21 -36 270 50 14
03-10 17:25:14.042 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 148 -12 -18 -35 290 50 12
03-10 17:25:15.019 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -79 -18 -18 -35 310 50 11
03-10 17:25:16.034 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 74 11 -18 -33 330 50 6
03-10 17:25:17.011 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -158 -17 -13 -32 350 50 3
03-10 17:25:18.026 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -4 -4 -13 -31 370 50 12
03-10 17:25:19.034 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 78 -10 -16 -30 390 50 14
03-10 17:25:20.020 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -56 -24 -16 -30 410 50 7
03-10 17:25:21.026 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 -16 -27 430 50 1
03-10 17:25:22.042 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 161 4 -10 -27 450 50 2
03-10 17:25:23.021 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -52 5 -10 -26 470 50 3
03-10 17:25:24.035 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 86 -15 -12 -26 490 50 9
03-10 17:25:24.567 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pBuffer->full() && (abs(median_) > 2): -2651
03-10 17:25:25.015 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -33 97 97 97 8 50 4
03-10 17:25:26.027 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 82 82 82 82 28 50 0
03-10 17:25:27.036 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 179 108 86 86 48 50 0
03-10 17:25:28.019 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 7 60 80 80 68 50 0
03-10 17:25:29.027 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 85 74 79 79 88 50 0
03-10 17:25:29.675 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pShortBuffer->full() && (abs(shortMedian_) > 5): 7901
03-10 17:25:30.042 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 114 52 52 52 6 50 0
03-10 17:25:31.018 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -122 -65 -52 -52 26 50 0
03-10 17:25:32.034 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 36 -28 -44 -44 46 50 0
03-10 17:25:33.011 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -198 -52 -52 -52 66 50 0
03-10 17:25:34.029 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -20 -26 -45 -45 86 50 0
03-10 17:25:35.034 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 36 -60 -52 -52 106 50 4
03-10 17:25:35.061 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pShortBuffer->full() && (abs(shortMedian_) > 5): -5237
03-10 17:25:36.020 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -22 46 46 46 18 50 0
03-10 17:25:37.026 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 38 55 46 46 38 50 0
03-10 17:25:38.042 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 195 77 46 46 58 50 0
03-10 17:25:39.024 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 21 43 43 43 78 50 0
03-10 17:25:40.035 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 127 24 42 42 98 50 0
03-10 17:25:41.014 19338 14667 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -80 40 40 40 118 50 -10
With OBOE (No Resampling):
03-10 17:27:18.458 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pBuffer->full() && (abs(median_) > 2): -3154
03-10 17:27:19.035 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 93 309 9
03-10 17:27:20.003 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 248 317 0
03-10 17:27:21.018 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: -1 -1 -1 0 418 310 0
03-10 17:27:22.004 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 330 2
03-10 17:27:23.002 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 310 0
03-10 17:27:24.026 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 310 0
03-10 17:27:25.003 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 325 0
03-10 17:27:26.010 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 310 0
03-10 17:27:27.005 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 0 500 338 0
03-10 17:27:28.002 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 315 -1
03-10 17:27:29.018 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 310 0
03-10 17:27:30.003 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 0 500 333 0
03-10 17:27:31.002 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 310 -2
03-10 17:27:32.026 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 310 0
03-10 17:27:33.003 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 323 0
03-10 17:27:34.010 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 310 0
03-10 17:27:35.001 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 0 500 336 0
03-10 17:27:36.003 19338 15073 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 2 1 500 301 -3
With OBOE & resampling:
03-10 17:28:38.266 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pBuffer->full() && (abs(median_) > 2): -4294
03-10 17:28:39.004 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 132 338 7
03-10 17:28:40.000 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 292 315 0
03-10 17:28:41.019 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 471 310 0
03-10 17:28:42.004 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 0 0 500 330 0
03-10 17:28:43.003 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 0 500 310 0
03-10 17:28:44.027 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 1 500 310 -2
03-10 17:28:45.004 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 1 500 323 -2
03-10 17:28:46.011 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 310 0
03-10 17:28:47.035 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 309 0
03-10 17:28:48.005 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 315 0
03-10 17:28:49.019 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 0 0 0 500 310 0
03-10 17:28:50.004 19338 15324 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 0 500 333 0
FYI.. i didnt test it before, but with OBOE & RESAMPLING both enabled, the FireTV plays even when the TV goes off. However, it stopped as before after some time playing.
Once it stops playing, and i turn off and on again on the local client app (while being muted) the log gets spammed by this:
03-10 17:45:03.398 19338 18851 D Main : [Info] (Stream) no chunks available
03-10 17:45:03.423 19338 18851 I chatty : uid=10177(de.badaix.snapcast) Thread-12 identical 8 lines
03-10 17:45:03.432 19338 18851 D Main : [Info] (Stream) no chunks available
03-10 17:45:03.462 19338 18851 D Main : [Info] (Stream) no chunks available
03-10 17:45:03.487 19338 18851 I chatty : uid=10177(de.badaix.snapcast) Thread-12 identical 9 lines
03-10 17:45:03.496 19338 18851 D Main : [Info] (Stream) no chunks available
03-10 17:45:03.526 19338 18851 D Main : [Info] (Stream) no chunks available
03-10 17:45:03.551 19338 18851 I chatty : uid=10177(de.badaix.snapcast) Thread-12 identical 8 lines
03-10 17:45:03.559 19338 18851 D Main : [Info] (Stream) no chunks available
03-10 17:45:03.590 19338 18851 D Main : [Info] (Stream) no chunks available
03-10 17:45:03.615 19338 18851 I chatty : uid=10177(de.badaix.snapcast) Thread-12 identical 9 lines
03-10 17:45:03.624 19338 18851 D Main : [Info] (Stream) no chunks available
I tried capturing the exact point of stop playing with the logcat. But so far i have not been able to do so. However, not taking the logcat and muting it for some minutes, then trying to unmute it is showing this problem quite well.
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
This spam should also happen directly when muting, not only after mute/stop/start. This is the "smaller fix" I mentioned yesterday. To not spam the log buffer too much, I've limited the message to show up only once per second.
Seems that your fireTV is quite unimpressed of the used sample rate. These messages will cause audible audio drops:
03-10 17:20:22.464 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pShortBuffer->full() && (abs(shortMedian_) > 5): 34146
03-10 17:20:29.061 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pShortBuffer->full() && (abs(shortMedian_) > 5): -6945
03-10 17:20:34.162 19338 21858 D Main : [Info] (Stream) pShortBuffer->full() && (abs(shortMedian_) > 5): 7071
This is why Oboe should be preferred by Snapdroid (I don't want to implement a pure AAudio player, as Oboe is according to Google the recommended "one size fits all" solution, and it's dead simple to use (but if I would completely trust in Oboe, I would have removed the OpenSL player...).
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
I found this on developer.amazon.com:
Requirement 6.1: Keeping the Device Awake
You must keep the device awake while playback is expected. This usually means your application sets the Activity flag FLAG_KEEP_SCREEN_ON or implements dynamic wake lock management by acquiring FULL_WAKE_LOCK.Note: When using FLAG_KEEP_SCREEN_ON, you must unset the flag when playback is paused.
The attached APK will aquire a FULL_WAKE_LOCK (which is deprecated, but since audio is played from a service, and a PARTIAL_WAKE_LOCK is already aquired there, it's now simply using the full or the partial lock, depending on the device type it's running on):
Snapcast_0.19.0.1_1903_full_wake_lock.apk.zip
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
Thank you. I am trying the new version. FYI just found a new bug. In the new app (on FireTV) when the Play/Stop Symbol is selected: Click once left and twice right and the app will crash.
The new app stops playing as soon as i turn off the Soundbar. When OBOE is selected.
I took the log of the libsnapclient.so
03-10 23:19:42.138 11320 11320 W libsnapclient.s: type=1400 audit(0.0:8417): avc: denied { ioctl } for path="socket:[4155738]" dev="sockfs" ino=4155738 ioctlcmd=0x8927 scontext=u:r:untrusted_app:s0:c177,c256,c512,c768 tcontext=u:r:untrusted_app:s0:c177,c256,c512,c768 tclass=tcp_socket permissive=0
03-10 23:19:42.138 11320 11320 W libsnapclient.s: type=1400 audit(0.0:8418): avc: denied { search } for name="net" dev="sysfs" ino=10143 scontext=u:r:untrusted_app:s0:c177,c256,c512,c768 tcontext=u:object_r:sysfs_net:s0 tclass=dir permissive=0
03-10 23:19:42.148 11320 11323 D AAudio : AAudioStreamBuilder_openStream() called ----------------------------------------
03-10 23:19:42.148 11320 11323 D AudioStreamBuilder: build() EXCLUSIVE sharing mode not supported. Use SHARED.
03-10 23:19:42.148 11320 11323 D : PlayerBase::PlayerBase()
03-10 23:19:42.148 11320 11323 I AAudioStream: open() rate = 44100, channels = 2, format = 1, sharing = SH, dir = OUTPUT
03-10 23:19:42.148 11320 11323 I AAudioStream: open() device = 0, sessionId = 0, perfMode = 12, callback: ON with frames = 0
03-10 23:19:42.148 11320 11323 I AAudioStream: open() usage = 1, contentType = 2, inputPreset = 6
03-10 23:19:42.148 11320 11323 D AudioStreamTrack: open(), request notificationFrames = -8, frameCount = 0
03-10 23:19:42.151 11320 11323 W AudioTrack: AUDIO_OUTPUT_FLAG_FAST denied by server; frameCount 0 -> 1418
03-10 23:19:42.154 11320 11323 W AudioStreamTrack: open() flags changed from 0x00000104 to 0x00000000
03-10 23:19:42.154 11320 11323 W AudioStreamTrack: open() perfMode changed from 12 to 10
03-10 23:19:42.154 11320 11323 D AAudio : AAudioStreamBuilder_openStream() returns 0 = AAUDIO_OK for (0xe4fde000) ----------------
03-10 23:19:42.154 11320 11323 D AAudio : AAudioStream_requestStart(0xe4fde000) called --------------
03-10 23:19:42.154 11320 11323 D : PlayerBase::start() from IPlayer
03-10 23:19:42.155 11320 11323 D AAudio : AAudioStream_requestStart(0xe4fde000) returned 0 ---------
03-10 23:21:49.826 11320 11324 W AudioTrack: dead IAudioTrack, PCM, creating a new one from processAudioBuffer()
03-10 23:21:49.826 11320 11325 W AudioSystem: ioConfigChanged() closing unknown output 5565
03-10 23:21:49.861 11320 11324 W AudioTrack: AUDIO_OUTPUT_FLAG_FAST denied by server; frameCount 1418 -> 1772
03-10 23:21:49.893 11320 11324 D AudioStreamLegacy: processCallbackCommon() stream disconnected
03-10 23:21:49.893 11320 11324 W AudioStreamLegacy: processCallbackCommon() data, stream disconnected
03-10 23:21:49.893 11320 11324 E AudioTrack: EVENT_MORE_DATA requested 2360 bytes but callback returned -1 bytes
03-10 23:21:49.895 11320 11685 D AAudio : AAudioStream_requestStop(0xe4fde000)
03-10 23:21:49.895 11320 11685 D : PlayerBase::stop() from IPlayer
03-10 23:21:49.895 11320 11685 E AAudioStream: setState(0xe4fde000) tried to set to 9 but already DISCONNECTED
03-10 23:21:49.895 11320 11685 D AudioTrack: stop() called with 5631904 frames delivered
03-10 23:21:49.897 11320 11685 D AAudio : AAudioStream_close(0xe4fde000) called ---------------
03-10 23:21:49.898 11320 11320 W AudioTrack: type=1400 audit(0.0:8424): avc: denied { read } for name="u:object_r:media_prop:s0" dev="tmpfs" ino=14226 scontext=u:r:untrusted_app:s0:c177,c256,c512,c768 tcontext=u:object_r:media_prop:s0 tclass=file permissive=0
03-10 23:21:49.899 11320 11685 E libc : Access denied finding property "media.metrics.enabled"
03-10 23:21:49.901 11320 11685 D AAudioStream: destroying 0xe4fde000, state = AAUDIO_STREAM_STATE_CLOSED
03-10 23:21:49.901 11320 11685 D AAudio : AAudioStream_close(0xe4fde000) returned 0 ---------
Taking the normal log shows nothing. When i turn off the soundbar, the log just stops. No more music is being played. Only new entries when i change the volume:
03-10 23:24:56.003 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 336 -2
03-10 23:24:57.002 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 0 500 318 0
03-10 23:24:58.018 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 1 0 500 310 -2
03-10 23:24:59.007 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 328 -1
03-10 23:25:00.002 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 310 0
03-10 23:25:01.026 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 0 500 310 0
03-10 23:25:02.000 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 2 2 2 1 500 321 -2
03-10 23:25:03.010 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 1 1 500 310 -5
03-10 23:25:04.034 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 1 500 310 0
03-10 23:25:05.003 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 315 0
03-10 23:25:06.018 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 1 0 500 310 0
03-10 23:25:07.002 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 0 0 0 0 500 328 -2
03-10 23:25:08.002 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (Stream) Chunk: 1 1 0 1 500 310 0
03-10 23:25:43.594 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (onMessageReceived) ServerSettings - buffer: 1000, latency: 440, volume: 26, muted: 1
03-10 23:25:43.595 11251 11274 D TCP : Received Message: '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"Client.OnVolumeChanged","params":{"id":"7d90ab52-887e-4145-92bb-c8384d7422b5","volume":{"muted":true,"percent":26}}}'
03-10 23:25:44.667 11251 12179 D Main : [Info] (onMessageReceived) ServerSettings - buffer: 1000, latency: 440, volume: 26, muted: 0
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
What soundbar?
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
My FireTV is connected to a soundbar which then goes into the TV via HDMI. Samsung Brand Soundbar.
from snapdroid.
badaix
commented on June 18, 2024
Until now it was about switching off the TV?
from snapdroid.
almostserious
commented on June 18, 2024
Previously when I turned off the TV but let the Soundbar on, the stream stopped playing after some time. Now, i realized that the stream stops playing immediately when I turn off the Soundbar. In any case, i wonder if this might be some CEC related issue. The device connected to the FireTV turns off and that kills the stream? Ill have to check if there is some CEC settings on FireTV and disable that.
EDIT
So, i played around a bit more.
I installed an old version again to see if there are differences.
Turned off CEC completely.
Connected the FireTV to the TV directly.
Changing App Version makes no difference.
Turning off CEC makes no difference.
Turning off the direct HDMI connected device (Both Soundbar & TV) stops playback. Even just switching the source stops the playback.
from snapdroid.
Related Issues (20)
- Can connect with IP but not with hostname HOT 2
- android stream source
- Audio Drops on Android Clients HOT 1
- Change play/stop icons
- Modern Redesign of the App
- compile snapcast server HOT 7
- App has disappeared from the Play store HOT 5
- Snapdroid does not play any audio HOT 4
- Add option to show ID instead of HOST Field in Stream Overview
- [Feature request] Basic Buttons to control an MPD server /next, play, back/ -
- Build Snapdroid in Windows 10 HOT 2
- Allow HTTP connections
- Start/ Stop client with ADB HOT 1
- Android: Snapdroid thin client HOT 1
- Snapclient.so not found HOT 1
- "error: Connection refused" HOT 2
- No sound on android client
- Snapdroid clients disconnect after ~12 hours on recent Android versions HOT 1
- Run client without RPC support
- description for how to use the GUI
Recommend Projects
-
React
A declarative, efficient, and flexible JavaScript library for building user interfaces.
-
Vue.js
🖖 Vue.js is a progressive, incrementally-adoptable JavaScript framework for building UI on the web.
-
Typescript
TypeScript is a superset of JavaScript that compiles to clean JavaScript output.
-
TensorFlow
An Open Source Machine Learning Framework for Everyone
-
Django
The Web framework for perfectionists with deadlines.
-
Laravel
A PHP framework for web artisans
-
D3
Bring data to life with SVG, Canvas and HTML. 📊📈🎉
-
Recommend Topics
-
javascript
JavaScript (JS) is a lightweight interpreted programming language with first-class functions.
-
web
Some thing interesting about web. New door for the world.
-
server
A server is a program made to process requests and deliver data to clients.
-
Machine learning
Machine learning is a way of modeling and interpreting data that allows a piece of software to respond intelligently.
-
Visualization
Some thing interesting about visualization, use data art
-
Game
Some thing interesting about game, make everyone happy.
Recommend Org
-
Facebook
We are working to build community through open source technology. NB: members must have two-factor auth.
-
Microsoft
Open source projects and samples from Microsoft.
-
Google
Google ❤️ Open Source for everyone.
-
Alibaba
Alibaba Open Source for everyone
-
D3
Data-Driven Documents codes.
-
Tencent
China tencent open source team.
from snapdroid.